PubMed · 2005 · 30 citations · 5 references
MedicineMedical EducationSurgeryComputer-assisted InstructionGeneral SurgeryVirtual Reality In EducationLaparoscopic SurgerySimulation-based LearningSurgery EducationSurgical ResidencyVirtual RealityVirtual Reality In MedicineLaparoscopic SimulationOperative Performance AssessmentPerformance Score AnalysisRelative EfficiencySurgical SimulationSurgical Simulation TrainingSurgical Skill TrainingSurgical Training
BACKGROUND: Simulated environments present challenges to both clinical experts and novices in laparoscopic surgery. Experts and novices may have different expectations when confronted with a novel simulated environment. The LapSim is a computer-based virtual reality laparoscopic trainer. Our aim was to analyze the performance of experienced basic laparoscopists and novices during their first exposure to the LapSim Basic Skill set and Dissection module. METHODS: Experienced basic laparoscopists (n=16) were defined as attending surgeons and chief residents who performed >30 laparoscopic cholecystectomies. Novices (n=13) were surgical residents with minimal laparoscopic experience. None of the subjects had used a computer-based laparoscopic simulator in the past. Subjects were given one practice session on the LapSim tutorial and dissection module and were supervised throughout the testing. Instrument motion, completion time, and errors were recorded by the LapSim. A Performance Score (PS) was calculated using the sum of total errors and time to task completion. A Relative Efficiency Score (RES) was calculated using the sum of the path lengths and angular path lengths for each hand expressed as a ratio of the subject's score to the worst score achieved among the subjects. All groups were compared using the Kruskal-Wallis and Mann-Whitney U-test. RESULTS: Novices achieved better PS and/or RES in Instrument Navigation, Suturing, and Dissection (p<0.05). There was no difference in the PS and RES between experts and novices in the remaining skills. CONCLUSION: Novices tended to have better performance compared to the experienced basic laparoscopists during their first exposure to the LapSim Basic Skill set and Dissection module.
5
Laparoscopic virtual reality and box trainers: is one superior to the other?
S Bann, Ara Darzi, Yaron Munz et al. · Surgical Endoscopy · 2004 · 352 citations
N Taffinder, Chris Sutton, R J Fishwick et al. · Studies in health technology and informatics · 1998 · 264 citations
Daniel Scott, William N. Young, Seifu T. Tesfay et al. · The American Journal of Surgery · 2001 · 166 citations