Choice Reviews Online · 2003 · 171 citations · 0 references
Social SciencesEconomicsPolitical ScienceBehavioral EconomicsDemocratizationPolitical EconomyComparative Political EconomyElectionsPolitical RiskProspect TheoryRational ChoiceRisk AversionComparative Economic PolicyIncumbent Re-election AdvantagePolitical Risk PerceptionProspect Theory Applications
The study examines why fragile democratic leaders succeed or fail when implementing painful economic reforms, noting that prospect theory predicts risk‑taking in perceived losses and caution in perceived gains. The author investigates why presidents in Argentina, Brazil, Peru, and Venezuela pursue bold reforms and receive popular support, arguing that prospect theory is essential to explain these political outcomes. The analysis shows that conventional rational‑choice models fail, while prospect theory explains that crises prompt public support for harsh reforms that can lead to economic recovery.
An examination of a question central to comparative politics and economics: Why do some leaders of fragile democracies attain political success - culminating in re-election victories - when pursuing drastic, painful economic reforms while others see their political careers implode? Kurt Weyland examines, in particular, the surprising willingness of presidents in four Latin American countries to enact daring reforms and the unexpected popular support. He argues that only with the robust cognitive-psychological insights of prospect theory can one fully account for the twists and turns of politics and economic policy in Argentina, Brazil, Peru, and Venezuela during the 1980s and 1990s. Assessing conventional approaches such as rational choice, Weyland concludes that prospect theory is vital to any systematic attempt to understand the politcs of market reform. Under this theory, if actors perceive themselves to be in a losing situation they are inclined toward risks; if they see a winning situation around them, they prefer caution. In Latin America, Weyland finds, where the public faced an open crisis it backed draconian reforms. And where such reforms yielded an apparent economic reco