Quality Loss Functions for Optimization across Multiple Response Surfaces

Allan E. Ames, Neil Mattucci, Stephen MacDonald, Geza Szonyi, Douglas M. Hawkins

Journal of Quality Technology · 1997 · 165 citations · 17 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Manufacturing must meet multiple fitness‑for‑use criteria, requiring design parameter settings that balance these needs to maximize product quality. The study proposes using quadratic quality loss functions on response surface models to address the multiple‑criterion design problem. The method focuses on the premanufacturing phase where off‑target losses dominate, though it also applies when both off‑target and random‑variability losses are significant. Operating at the loss‑function minimum simultaneously minimizes product sensitivity to design‑parameter noise, yielding inherently robust designs.

Abstract

Most manufactured products must conform to multiple "fitness for use" criteria. The manufacturing design must balance these different needs and find settings of design parameters that maximize product quality. This paper proposes the use of quadratic quality loss functions applied to response surface models to solve this multiple criterion problem. The discussion concentrates on the premanufacturing phase, when off-target losses predominate over losses due to random variability, but the methodology is equally applicable to situations in which both sources contribute appreciably to quality losses. It is shown that operating a process at the minimum of the loss function has the additional benefit of minimizing sensitivity of the product to noise variation in the design parameter settings, leading to robust designs automatically.

References

17