Language Cognition and Neuroscience · 2015 · 232 citations · 88 references
Language StudiesLinguisticsPsychologyCognitive PsychologyNeurolinguisticsPsycholinguisticsCognitive ModelingLanguage InputLanguage LearningLanguage ProcessingLanguage Processing ModelsPredictive Processing In LanguageResource Limitations
Some recent theoretical accounts in the cognitive sciences suggest that prediction is necessary to understand language. Here we evaluate this proposal. We consider arguments that prediction provides a unified theoretical principle of the human mind and that it pervades cortical function. We discuss whether evidence of human abilities to detect statistical regularities is necessarily evidence for predictive processing and evaluate suggestions that prediction is necessary for language learning. We point out that not all language users appear to predict language and that suboptimal input makes prediction often very challenging. Prediction, moreover, is strongly context-dependent and impeded by resource limitations. We also argue that it may be problematic that most experimental evidence for predictive language processing comes from “prediction-encouraging” experimental set-ups. We conclude that languages can be learned and understood in the absence of prediction. Claims that all language processing is predictive in nature are premature.
88
Jeffrey L. Elman · Cognitive Science · 1990 · 10.8K citations
Statistical Learning by 8-Month-Old Infants
Jenny R. Saffran, Richard Ν. Aslin, Elissa L. Newport · Science · 1996 · 5.7K citations
Education, Linguistics, Psychology +16
Expectation-based syntactic comprehension
Roger Lévy · Cognition · 2007 · 2.2K citations