Ergodic Theory

Overview

Definition and Key Concepts

traces its origins to questions in concerning the understanding of motion in , with the motion of planets around the sun being one of the earliest examples of such systems. Initially emerging as a hypothesis within statistical mechanics, ergodic theory has rapidly developed into a mature and influential area of . This evolution has allowed ergodic theory to interact with and contribute to various fields, establishing itself as a central topic in mathematical research.

At its core, ergodic theory examines how the long-term statistical behavior of a is influenced by its initial conditions. In ergodic systems, the long-term behavior is independent of the initial state, meaning that time averages converge to space averages under certain conditions. This property is formalized through the concept of invariant measures, which are central to the study of ergodic systems.

The study of isomorphism theory is a significant aspect of ergodic theory, focusing on the conditions under which two measure-preserving systems can be deemed equivalent. This branch of mathematics investigates various isomorphism invariants, with the Kolmogorov-Sinai being the most notable among them. The central theorem in this field, Ornstein's proof, establishes that any two Bernoulli shifts sharing the same entropy are isomorphic. Furthermore, measure-preserving dynamical systems are a key subject within the abstract formulation of dynamical systems and ergodic theory, adhering to the Poincaré recurrence theorem and representing a specific category of conservative systems.

Ergodic theory can be described as the statistical and qualitative behavior of measurable group and semigroup actions on measure spaces, with the groups most commonly being N, R, R-+, and Z. Its origins trace back to the work of Boltzmann in statistical mechanics, where it was established that time- and space-distribution averages are equal. As the theory developed within the realm of , it was rapidly formalized and extended, leading to ergodic theory becoming an independent area of mathematics. This evolution has resulted in multiple definitions of ergodicity and various of the concept across different fields. Today, ergodic theory stands as a mature and influential mathematical theory, reflecting its significant contributions to the understanding of dynamical systems.

Importance in Mathematics and Physics

Ergodic theory plays a crucial role in both mathematics and physics, particularly in the study of dynamical systems and statistical mechanics. It originated from the ergodic hypothesis, which addresses the long-term average behavior of systems and establishes a connection between the statistical properties of ensembles and the dynamics of individual systems. This foundational aspect of ergodic theory is essential for understanding , such as the behavior of gas molecules or the interactions of vibrating atoms in a crystal.

The principles of ergodic theory have their origins in statistical mechanics, where early pioneers such as Boltzmann, Maxwell, Gibbs, and Einstein developed the concept of ensembles to describe both equilibrium and nonequilibrium macroscopic systems. In their efforts to justify the use of these ensembles, they introduced key concepts like "ergodicity" and "coarse-graining" to explore how ensembles transition from nonequilibrium to equilibrium states. Furthermore, ergodic theory establishes a crucial connection between the ensembles studied in statistical mechanics and the properties of individual systems, particularly in addressing the equality of infinite time averages and phase averages. This foundational work underscores the significance of ergodic theory in understanding the relationship between microscopic dynamics and macroscopic statistical behavior.

Ergodic theory is a significant area of study that has been extended to more complex systems, including those exhibiting chaotic behavior, highlighting its relevance in various practical applications. This field unifies topics across ergodic theory, , , and dynamical systems, providing an accessible introduction that is appreciated by readers in both pure and . The theory is illustrated through examples and real-world connections, making it easier for students to grasp its principles. Overall, ergodic theory not only enriches theoretical understanding but also demonstrates its applicability in real-world scenarios, thereby enhancing its significance in the analysis of complex systems.

Moreover, ergodic theory's relevance is underscored by its foundational role in statistical mechanics, where it aids in studying the long-term average behavior of complex systems. The insights gained from ergodic theory not only enhance our understanding of physical systems but also contribute to the broader mathematical landscape, making it a vital area of study in both disciplines.

History

Early Developments

Ergodic theory emerged in the 1930s, primarily through the contributions of mathematicians such as John von Neumann, George Birkhoff, and George Koopman. These foundational figures laid the groundwork for understanding the statistical and qualitative behavior of measurable group and semigroup actions on measure spaces, which are central to ergodic theory. The discipline evolved from the deterministic of mid-19th century physics, which did not adequately address the probabilistic modeling of systems introduced by Ludwig Boltzmann and later clarified by Josiah Willard Gibbs.

The of ergodic theory is to utilize simple yet relevant models to gain deeper insights into concepts pertinent to statistical mechanics, while deliberately avoiding unnecessary technical complexities. This approach has allowed ergodic theory to challenge and complement traditional deterministic models, particularly in the context of physical systems such as gas models. For instance, the behavior of particles in bounded regions, exemplified by planar billiards, serves as a significant within ergodic theory and dynamical systems.

Moreover, the Ergodic Hypothesis, which posits that time averages and space averages are equivalent under certain conditions, was supported by proofs from von Neumann and others, confirming the validity of treating these averages as identical—a concept that had been intuitively accepted by physicists for years. Thus, the early developments in ergodic theory not only established a mathematical framework but also provided a new lens through which to view and analyze complex systems in physics and beyond.

Key Figures and Contributions

The development of ergodic theory, a branch of mathematics that studies the statistical properties of dynamical systems, reached a significant milestone in the early 1930s. During this period, American mathematician George D. Birkhoff and Austrian-Hungarian (and later American) mathematician and physicist John von Neumann independently reconsidered and reformulated Boltzmann's ergodic hypothesis. Their contributions were pivotal in establishing a deeper understanding of the relationship between time averages and space averages in dynamical systems, which is central to the concept of ergodicity. Additionally, von Neumann introduced the concept of measure-theoretic entropy, which was further developed by Leonid Khinchine, highlighting the importance of ergodic theory in both mathematics and physics.

George D. Birkhoff, an eminent American mathematician, is particularly renowned for formulating the ergodic theorem, which transformed the Maxwell-Boltzmann ergodic hypothesis into a rigorous mathematical principle. This theorem asserts that for almost all orbits in a measure-preserving dynamical system, the time average of a function equals its space average, provided the system is metrically transitive. Birkhoff's contributions extended beyond ergodic theory, impacting various areas such as and dynamical systems.

John von Neumann made significant contributions to ergodic theory, particularly through his foundational work in the early 1930s. His most important contributions during this period were centered on the statistical properties of , as ergodic theory studies these properties in depth. In two pivotal papers published in 1932, von Neumann contributed to the establishment of the ergodic theorem, which asserts the existence of time limits for any one-parameter measure-preserving group. Furthermore, it states that for almost all orbits, the time average of an integrable function on phase space is equal to its phase average, provided that the one-parameter group is metrically transitive. His collaboration with George Birkhoff was instrumental, as Birkhoff's work helped to solidify a more robust theorem in ergodic theory. Notably, von Neumann's sense of courtesy led him to renounce a claim of co-authorship on the second theorem, reflecting the collaborative of their research. Together, their contributions significantly shaped the foundational principles of ergodic theory.

In the early 1930s, a significant milestone in the development of ergodic theory was achieved when American mathematician George D. Birkhoff and Austrian-Hungarian (and later American) mathematician and physicist John von Neumann separately reconsidered and reformulated Boltzmann's ergodic hypothesis, which contributed to the theoretical rigor of the field. This period marked the emergence of the concept of ergodicity, as researchers began to explore the relationship between time averages and space averages in dynamical systems. Von Neumann's introduction of measure-theoretic entropy further advanced the field, demonstrating the importance of ergodic theory in understanding complex phenomena across mathematics and physics. Their foundational contributions continue to influence various applications and the study of statistical properties within dynamical systems.

Fundamental Theorems

Birkhoff's Ergodic Theorem

Birkhoff's Ergodic Theorem is a cornerstone of ergodic theory, establishing a profound connection between time averages and space averages within dynamical systems. The theorem asserts that for a measure-preserving transformation ( T ) on a measure space ( X ), the time average of an integrable function along the trajectories converges to the space average almost everywhere, provided that the transformation is ergodic and the measure is invariant. Specifically, if ( f ) is an integrable function, then the limit of the time average ( \lim_{n o \infty} \frac{1}{n} \sum_{k=0}^{n-1} f(T^k x) ) equals the space average ( \int_X f , d\mu ) for almost all points ( x \in X ).

Birkhoff's Ergodic Theorem is a fundamental result in ergodic theory, which provides a mathematical framework for analyzing the long-term average behavior of complex systems. This theorem states that under certain conditions, the time average of a function along the trajectories of a dynamical system exists almost everywhere and is related to the space average. Specifically, if the transformation is ergodic and the measure is invariant, the time average is equal to the space average almost everywhere. This principle is crucial in statistical mechanics, as it underpins the statistical approach by ensuring that time averages for a single system over a long period are equivalent to ensemble averages across many systems at a fixed time. The applications of ergodic theory are extensive, particularly in understanding the behavior of molecules in a gas and the interactions of vibrating atoms in a crystal, thereby bridging the gap between theoretical models and experimental observations.

Moreover, the 1931–1932 ergodic theorem, which applies to the phase space of , further reinforces Birkhoff's findings by asserting that for almost all orbits, the time average of an integrable function on phase space is equal to its phase average, given that the one-parameter group of homeomorphisms representing the time evolution of the system is metrically transitive. This result highlights the robustness of ergodic theory in providing a mathematical framework for understanding the long-term behavior of dynamical systems across various fields.

Von Neumann's Ergodic Theorem

Von Neumann's Ergodic Theorem is a foundational result in ergodic theory that establishes the relationship between time averages and space averages for measure-preserving transformations. This theorem asserts that for a measure-preserving system, the time average of a function along the orbits of almost every point converges to the space average of that function with respect to the invariant measure. Specifically, if ( f ) is an integrable function on a measure space and ( T ) is a measure-preserving transformation, then for almost every point ( x ), the limit

[

\lim_{n o \infty} \frac{1}{n} \sum_{i=0}^{n-1} f(T^i x) = \int f , d\mu

]

holds true, where ( \mu ) is the invariant measure associated with the transformation ( T ). This result is pivotal as it provides a rigorous framework for understanding the long-term behavior of dynamical systems, linking the concept of ergodicity with the existence of invariant measures.

Von Neumann's Ergodic Theorem is integral to various fields, particularly in statistical mechanics, where it is closely linked to the ergodic hypothesis. This hypothesis serves as a fundamental analytical tool in equilibrium statistical mechanics, asserting that the time average of an observable is equivalent to its expectation value. In the realm of decision-making, traditional models often assume that risk preferences are stable traits unique to individuals. However, a new theory, informed by the concept of ergodicity, suggests that these risk preferences can vary depending on the dynamic contexts in which decisions are made. This perspective indicates that risk preferences are not fixed but are influenced by the specific settings in which individuals make choices, marking a significant advancement in the application of ergodic theory beyond its mathematical foundations.

Applications

Statistical Mechanics

Ergodic theory is integral to statistical mechanics, particularly in analyzing systems with numerous particles. Central to this field is the Ergodic Hypothesis, which posits that time averages for a single system over an extended period equate to ensemble averages across multiple systems at a fixed time. This hypothesis connects macroscopic observations with microscopic laws of physics, enhancing our understanding of thermodynamic properties and phase transitions in complex systems.

The ergodic theorem, especially the 1931–1932 version, is crucial for mechanical systems' phase space analysis. It states that for almost all orbits, the time average of an integrable function on phase space equals its phase average, assuming the one-parameter group is metrically transitive. This theorem provides significant insights into the average behavior of dynamical systems over long periods, which is vital for statistical mechanics analysis.

In non-equilibrium systems, ergodic theory is particularly valuable. The Ergodic Hypothesis ensures that time averages align with ensemble averages, facilitating the description of non-equilibrium phenomena in terms of equilibrium fluctuations. This is especially relevant for systems near equilibrium. The ergodic theorem, when applied to mechanical systems, offers insights into their average behavior over time, provided they are metrically transitive. Ergodicity supports the notion that any initial condition will eventually conform to a statistical mechanics ensemble description, crucial for understanding phase transitions in various physical systems. Thus, ergodic theory not only provides a framework for analyzing complex dynamics but also deepens our comprehension of critical phenomena in statistical mechanics.

Beyond physics, ergodic theory's implications extend to predictive modeling in data science, where understanding the long-term average behavior of dynamical systems can enhance prediction accuracy based on historical data. This application is evident in fields like finance and healthcare, where predictive models use ergodic concepts to forecast future outcomes.

Connections with Other Fields

Ergodic theory has established significant connections with various fields, enhancing our understanding of complex systems and contributing to advancements in multiple disciplines. One of the primary applications of ergodic theory is in statistical mechanics, where it studies the long-term average behavior of dynamical systems, providing insights into the properties of single systems as they relate to statistical ensembles. This foundational link has facilitated the development of information engines and the application of entropy concepts across diverse systems, including chemical, electrical, and biological systems.

In the realm of biological systems, ergodic theory has proven particularly useful in understanding complex phenomena. For instance, it aids in analyzing how biological systems utilize free energy to create informational constraints, thereby performing work and maintaining order within the system. Additionally, ergodic-theoretic techniques have been employed to study chaotic and turbulent natural phenomena, further bridging the gap between and practical applications in .

Ergodic theory plays a crucial role in the field of , particularly in the context of stochastic processes. The ergodic theorem is instrumental for training models that require an understanding of over time, as it enables the formulation of algorithms that can adapt to changing conditions by leveraging the statistical properties of underlying dynamical systems. This adaptability is essential for the development of practical algorithms, as it establishes a theoretical foundation for ergodic , which is vital for future and . Furthermore, the insights gained from ergodic theory contribute to bridging the gap between theoretical frameworks and practical applications, particularly in the context of Langevin-based (MCMC) methods, where it aids in algorithm design, parameter tuning, and convergence diagnostics.

Ergodic theory is a mathematical discipline that focuses on the analysis of the asymptotic or long-range behavior of dynamical systems using probabilistic methods. This field encompasses a rich variety of research areas, including ergodic theory, topological dynamics, complex dynamics, and dynamical systems, thereby providing an accessible introduction to its applications. The journal "Ergodic Theory and Dynamical Systems" highlights the importance of these diverse topics and brings together significant contributions in the field. Recent research has also delved into collaborative , illustrating the interdisciplinary applications of ergodic theory in this area. These developments emphasize the relevance of ergodic methods in enhancing our understanding across various scientific domains.

Recent Advancements

Measure-Theoretic Entropy

Recent advancements in ergodic theory have significantly enhanced the understanding of measure-theoretic entropy, a crucial concept in the study of dynamical systems. Measure-theoretic entropy provides a quantitative measure of the complexity or unpredictability of a dynamical system, reflecting how information is generated over time. This concept has evolved through various theoretical developments, particularly in the context of ergodic systems.

One of the key advancements in this area is the exploration of the relationship between ergodicity and entropy. The ergodic theorem asserts that under certain conditions, the time average of a function along the trajectories of a dynamical system exists almost everywhere and is related to the space average. Specifically, if the transformation is ergodic and the measure is invariant, the time average equals the space average almost everywhere, which is foundational for understanding entropy in ergodic systems.

Furthermore, recent research has delved into the implications of measure-theoretic entropy in various applications, including statistical mechanics. Ergodic theory serves as a mathematical framework to analyze the long-term average behavior of complex systems, such as the interactions of molecules in a gas or the dynamics of vibrating atoms in a crystal. This interplay between ergodic theory and statistical mechanics highlights the importance of measure-theoretic entropy in providing insights into the behavior of physical systems.

Recent advancements in ergodic theory and dynamical systems have significantly enhanced the understanding of weak mixing and Bernoulli actions. This review highlights the interplay between the actions of groups, particularly those with property T, and presents significant results, including the work of S. Popa on the characteristics of Bernoulli shifts. As a mixture of survey papers on active research areas and original research contributions, this volume attracts both young and senior researchers alike.

Weak Mixing and Bernoulli Actions

Weak mixing and Bernoulli actions are essential concepts within ergodic theory, which is structured around the Ergodic Hierarchy (EH). This hierarchy categorizes dynamical systems based on their mixing properties, encompassing five levels: ergodicity, weak mixing, strong mixing, Kolmogorov, and Bernoulli. Weak mixing indicates a certain degree of independence between the future and past states of a system, while Bernoulli actions represent a much stronger form of mixing, where the probability of future states is independent of the system's . These concepts not only enhance the theoretical framework of dynamical systems but also have practical applications in fields such as and randomness.

Recent developments have highlighted the importance of weakly mixing one-parameter actions, suggesting that this concept could extend to actions of more general groups. This exploration not only broadens the applicability of weak mixing but also provides a framework for understanding more complex dynamical systems. For instance, a simple criterion has been established for a non-singular and conservative Bernoulli action to possess a weakly mixing Maharam extension. This finding is particularly noteworthy as it demonstrates that every countable amenable group can support a stable type III_1 Bernoulli action, addressing a question posed by researchers Vaes and Wahl.

The implications of these advancements are profound, as they not only deepen theoretical insights into the nature of mixing in dynamical systems but also pave the way for practical applications in fields such as statistical physics and randomness. By elucidating the relationships between different degrees of mixing, researchers can better understand the underlying mechanisms that govern complex systems, thereby enhancing the overall comprehension of dynamical behavior in various contexts.

Ergodic Transformations

Definition and Characteristics

Ergodic transformations are defined as measure-preserving transformations of a probability space, and they exhibit specific statistical properties over time. In an ergodic scenario, any actor participating in the system can be classified as either ergodic or non-ergodic. A transformation ( T ) is considered ergodic if, for any measurable function ( f ) that is invariant under ( T ), the function must be almost everywhere constant. This implies that the average outcome of the group is equivalent to the average outcome of the individual over time, which is a defining characteristic of ergodic systems. A simple example illustrating this concept is the outcomes of a coin toss, where the average results converge regardless of whether 100 people flip a coin once or one person flips a coin multiple times.

One of the foundational results in ergodic theory is Birkhoff's Ergodic Theorem, which states that for an ergodic measure-preserving transformation ( T ) of a probability space ( (X, B, \mu) ), the time average of a function ( f ) converges to the space average almost everywhere as time progresses. Specifically, for any function ( f ) in ( L^1(X, B, \mu) ), the limit of the time averages approaches the integral of ( f ) with respect to the measure ( \mu ). This theorem highlights the significance of ergodicity in establishing a unique state of , as it ensures that the time average reflects the statistical properties of the system.

Ergodic transformations are also characterized by their relationship to various ergodic theorems, which assert that under certain conditions, the time average of a function along the trajectories exists almost everywhere and is related to the space average. In ergodic systems, the invariance of the measure plays a crucial role in ensuring that these averages coincide. Furthermore, ergodic transformations can be constructed using various mathematical tools, such as Lego-like constructions that allow for the development of complex transformations from simpler ones.

In the study of dynamical systems, actors within a system can be classified as either ergodic or non-ergodic. An ergodic scenario is defined by the property that the average outcome of the group is the same as the average outcome of the individual over time. For instance, in an ergodic system, the outcomes of a coin toss illustrate this concept; if 100 people flip a coin once, the results will converge to the same average as if one person flips a coin multiple times. Conversely, non-ergodic systems do not exhibit this property, as they may involve dynamics that do not stabilize to a single average outcome. This distinction is crucial for understanding the long-term behaviors of dynamical systems, as ergodic transformations ensure consistency in outcomes, while non-ergodic transformations can lead to varied and unpredictable results.

Examples and Intuition

Ergodic transformations play a crucial role in various fields, providing insights into complex systems and enhancing our understanding of statistical mechanics, , and chaotic dynamics. The Birkhoff Ergodic Theorem, established in 1931, serves as a foundational principle that connects time averages and space averages in ergodic systems. It asserts that if a transformation is ergodic and the measure is invariant, then the time average of a function along the trajectories exists almost everywhere and is equal to the space average. This theorem has significant implications in , , and , illustrating its broad applicability.

In statistical mechanics, ergodic transformations provide a rationale for the hypothesis that time averages can be equated with phase averages, which is essential for understanding thermodynamic equilibrium in physical systems. The Ergodic Hypothesis underpins the statistical approach by ensuring that the time averages for a single system over a long period are equivalent to the ensemble averages across many systems at a fixed time. This concept is pivotal in bridging macroscopic observations with microscopic laws of physics, thereby enhancing our comprehension of thermodynamic behavior.

Ergodic transformations have gained recognition for their importance in information theory, particularly within the realm of source coding theory. Information theorists frequently utilize the ergodic theorem, and concepts of entropy are also integral to the field. The relationship between ergodic theory and information theory has become increasingly intertwined, with deeper results from each discipline finding applications in the other. This interaction has led to a variety of applications of ergodic theoretic techniques, especially in proving source coding theorems for sliding block codes and employing process distance measures to establish universal source coding theorems. A comprehensive examination of these applications highlights the significant role that ergodic transformations play in enhancing our understanding of complex systems in information theory and related fields.

Chaotic dynamical systems are defined by their unpredictable and complex behaviors, a concept recognized since the work of mathematicians such as Hadamard and Poincaré, although it gained significant in the 1960s. The importance of these systems extends beyond mathematics, influencing various fields where their dynamics are relevant. Ergodic theory is particularly significant in this context, as it provides insights into the long-term statistical properties that arise from the complex behaviors of chaotic systems. This relationship is crucial for understanding various phenomena, including turbulence and , which are observed in both physical and mathematical contexts.

Interdisciplinary Connections

Relationship with Number Theory

The relationship between ergodic theory and number theory has been significantly advanced through the work of mathematicians such as Ben Green and Terence Tao, particularly with the formulation of the Green-Tao theorem in 2004. This theorem asserts that the sequence of prime numbers contains arbitrarily long arithmetic progressions, a result that was previously conjectured but not proven. The proof employs a combination of methods from both and ergodic theory, illustrating a profound interaction between these two fields.

The Green-Tao theorem represents a remarkable integration of analytic number theory and ergodic theory, demonstrating that for any positive integer ( k ), there exist infinitely many arithmetic progressions of length ( k ) composed solely of prime numbers. The theorem begins with the observation that the set ( P ) of prime numbers is too sparse to directly infer the existence of such arithmetic progressions using established estimates, such as those provided by the prime number theorem, which states that ( |P \cap [1,N]| \sim N \log N ) as ( N o \infty ). To overcome this limitation, Green and Tao consider the primes as a subset of a larger set of "almost primes," which facilitates the application of ergodic methods to achieve their results.

The relationship between ergodic theory and number theory has been significantly shaped by the work of mathematicians such as Furstenberg, whose proof of Szemerédi's Theorem marked a foundational moment in this interaction. This collaboration has primarily involved the application of ergodic theory to prove results in combinatorial number theory, leading to notable advancements in the field. Among the significant results are the Green-Tao theorem and the Elkies-McMullen theorem, which highlight the effectiveness of ergodic concepts in providing insights into the distribution of prime numbers and the structure of arithmetic progressions. Furthermore, the problem of higher-order mixing for commuting group automorphisms exemplifies the dialogue between these two disciplines, where deep results from number theory have been employed to address challenges in ergodic theory, and vice versa. This reciprocal influence underscores the potential for ongoing exploration and development within both fields.

Applications in Probability Theory

Ergodic theory has significant applications in , particularly in its connections with and statistical mechanics. The interplay between ergodic theory and probability is evident in the way ergodic results are often derived using techniques from analysis or probability itself, highlighting the interdisciplinary nature of these fields.

Ergodic theory plays a crucial role in the foundations of equilibrium statistical mechanics by linking thermodynamic observables with microcanonical probabilities. The ergodic theorem demonstrates the equality of microcanonical phase averages and infinite time averages, particularly for a specific class of systems. This relationship is essential as it establishes that the microcanonical measure is the appropriate probability measure for the statistical mechanical treatment of isolated systems in equilibrium. Furthermore, the first corollary of the ergodic theorem indicates that for metrically transitive systems, time average probabilities are equal to the microcanonical measure, with exceptions of m-measure zero. This framework helps explain why microcanonical averages effectively predict the values of thermodynamic observations, thereby reinforcing the significance of ergodic theory in understanding thermodynamic equilibrium.

Moreover, the concepts of microstates and macrostates in statistical mechanics are intricately linked to ergodic theory. Microstates represent the fine-grained configurations of a system, while macrostates provide a coarse-grained description. The multiplicity of microstates corresponding to a macrostate is essential for analyzing statistical properties and predicting macroscopic behavior, thereby facilitating a deeper understanding of equilibrium conditions, entropy, and phase transitions.

References

7

Ergodicity - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

11

PDF

wwwf.imperial.ac.uk

21

PDF

ndsu.edu

22

PDF

math.uchicago.edu

39

PDF

sfu.ca

48

PDF

math.uchicago.edu

51

PDF

w1.mtsu.edu

74

PDF

math.berkeley.edu

85

Ergodic theory - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

106

Ergodic theory - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

112

PDF

petersen.web.unc.edu

126

PDF

ocw.mit.edu

130

PDF

birs.ca

131

PDF

ndsu.edu

148

PDF

people.math.osu.edu

149

PDF

cims.nyu.edu

175

Ergodic theory - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

177

Ergodic theory - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

178

PDF

simonrs.com

183

PDF

ee.stanford.edu

187

PDF

mcgill.ca

209

PDF

nyjm.albany.edu

218

PDF

math.uzh.ch

221

PDF

math.northwestern.edu

235

PDF

phil.uu.nl