Necromancing the Stone: Archaeologists and Adzes in Samoa

Simon Best, Peter Sheppard, Roger Green, R. J. Parker

Journal of the Polynesian Society · 1992 · 86 citations · 11 references

Concepts

Abstract

Archaeologists are always on the lookout for evidence that prehistoric populations were in touch with one another. This is usually attainable, apart from often questionable stylistic similarities, only when a piece of the earth's surface from one area ends up in another, where it can be distinguished from the local material by various analyses. There are pitfalls, of course: even across large water gaps humans may not be the only agent of transportation, with stones hitching a ride in the roots of drifting trees (Leach 1981:13,66), but, in general, it is a fairly safe bet that foreign matter in a site indicates human transportation. The history of such studies goes back almost 350 years (Shotton 1971:571) and in the last 30 years has become commonplace in archaeology, encompass ing many types of inorganic materials. In the Pacific only three major projects have been undertaken, featuring obsidian (Smith et al. 1977), sand temper in ceramics (Dickinson and Shutler 1979), and stone axes (Binns and McBride 1972). The first of these involves geochemical analysis, the others p?tro graphie examination. Stone tools in general have tended to fascinate Pacific Island archaeolo gists; many of these are manufactured from fine-grained basalts, and many Oceanic island groups contain these rocks in various quantities, often with evidence of exploitation in the form of substantial quarries. An analysis was carried out by Best in 1984, using p?trographie and geochemical data, which attempted to distinguish between various Oceanic island basalts, and to compare specific adzes obtained during research in Fiji with samples from the vicinity of a traditional quarry site in Samoa (Best 1989:398-407). Since then, the project has been enlarged by a more representative sample from this quarry; Tataga Matau at inland Leone on Tutuila, American Samoa (Best et al. 1989), and by another physically and geochemically separate quarry area at the base of the Tataga Matau hill; this is identified as the Leafu subsource (Fig. 1). Other researchers have recently located further adze sources on Tutuila, and examples of these have been added to the analysis (Clark 1989; Wright and Clark). In addition, the sample of archaeological material from other island groups has also been improved. In this paper, data are presented on 161 archaeological and geological 45

References

11