The Austrian Nation: Cultural Consciousness and Socio-Political Processes

Günter Bischof

The German Quarterly · 2004 · 17 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

Bruckmuller, Ernst. The Austrian Nation: CulturalConsciousness and Socio-Political Processes. Translated with an Afterword by Lowell A Bangerter. Riverside, CA: Ariadne 2003. 480 pp. $46.00 paperback. Starting with his Nation Osterreich (1984) updated in 1996, the Viennese social and economic historian Ernst Bruckmuller has produced a steady fare of publications on the question whether and (since) when Austria(ns) could claim nationhood and/or an Austrian identity. The updated version has now been published in English. One wonders why a translation now (and who paid for it), after the publications of two outstanding monographs in the U.S. on Austrian in the twentieth century by Michael P. Steinberg (The Meaning of the Salzburg Festival, Cornell UP 1990) and Peter Thaler (The Ambivalence of Identity, Purdue UP 2001), both of whose important scholarly findings and savvy theoretical frameworks have been ignored by Bruckmuller. It is no secret that debate about Austrian 'identity' ran riot during the 1970s and 1980s, noted the American intellectual historian William M. Johnston in a review essay on Friedrich Heer 's Place in the Debate on Austrian in Contemporary Austrian Studies [CAS] vol. VII (245). Bruckmuller thrives on this debate and follows in the footsteps of Heer, arguably the most brilliant Austrian historian in the twentieth century. Heer's encyclopedic but idiosyncratic Der Kampf um die osterreichische Identitat (1981, tellingly republished in the millennium year 1996) established the parameters of the discourse on this issue. Johnston characterized Heer's catholic intellectual style as a juxtaposition of incongruities (245). While Heer and Steinberg see the origins of Austrian in the rich cultural context of the Baroque period, Bruckmuller's strength is that he looks for even deeper traces and the foreshadowing of Austrian self-consciousness in the high medieval ages in the Habsburg court and the forming estates. Beyond the legal 'Austria concept he discerns ethnic content and ethnic already in the territorial formations of the late 13th century (155). He rightly pays much attention to the particularly strong regional consciousness in the Austrian lands/states (Tyrolean etc.). He treads familiar terrain in his analysis of Herder's role in the promotion of language consciousness and nationalism in the 19th century, the genesis of the various national identities among the Habsburg peoples, along with the struggle of German-Austrian vis-a-vis the Germans of Bismarck's Reich. Unlike Heer, Bruckmuller rightly dedicates a considerable part of his study to recent social science and polling data about the growing strength and self-assurance of Austrian consciousness in the post-World War II era. These data measuring identity have also been analyzed in Thaler's Ambivalence of Identity (161ff). Bruckmuller quibbles with Benedict Anderson's famous theory of nationalism as an invention of tradition (381ff), arguing that governments no longer have the power to construct collective historical memories from above. All they can do is select myths and symbols etc. from a rich historical inventory. This is ignoring evidence from Thaler who persuasively shows how hidebound high officials in the postwar Austrian Education Ministry invented a counter-German historical narrative that became the intellectual foundation of Austrian nation-building in the past half-century (Thaler, Ambivalence, 51ff). In other words, Education Ministry officials and staatstragende historians did construct a historical narrative that stressed Austrian and Habsburg roots and elided German elements and the common conflictual World War II past. …