Studies in Romanticism · 2009 · 14 citations · 0 references
HumanitiesLiteratureLiterary CriticismLiterary StudiesPoetryLiterary BalladsPoeticsBallad Form ClassificationCensus RegistersReception Of Poetry
WORDSWORTH'S WE ARE SEVEN--AN EARLY, PERHAPS EVEN SELF-teaching poem, and not his final statement about poetry and quantification, if there was one--dramatizes ballad form, its lowliest meters and their risk of doggerel, as a stubborn register of conflicts between old and new counts. A very few people inhabit a small scene. By unusually silent implication, it makes poetry, not prose, first, most dangerously concise medium through which to record conflicts over in larger scene. Randall Jarrell once made fun of academic village explainers of this poem as bad Magi visiting with bad gifts. Whatever fun of that laughter, poem, like some other aggressively awkward works, in fact invites ridicule and protracted commentary in order to survive them both as part of its projected action. Extremely drawn out reading of one poem is, also, a tradition of sorts, and could be something to revive now because a little out of favor. (1) As an aside, Wordsworth was, in fact, one of Jarrell's two poets, along with Rilke. Modes of census change, classical lustra (ritual purifications after census) also change into later, less obvious acts, and poetic mimicry of real Scene of Counting, using metrics to rethink public enumeration, has a broad if often partly hidden place in poetics. This poem's open, blunt mix of forced dialogue and balladry-about-elementary-numbering comes into focus, a little apart from critical tradition's emphasis, when read against eighteenth-century's many witty or unexpected genres (novel, tract, poem, dialogue, debate, and so on) used to frame acts of unofficial census and themes of population. (2) Necessarily clumsy, as a problem lyric, it acts out a deliberately lowest variant of eighteenth century's English population debates, and also belongs to a larger, more general impulse in world literature that could be called anti-census. (3) Though generally and accurately taken to be about nearness-and-farness of death, denials of death, children and adults in dialogue, and moral-instructional timing, its ironically charcoaled structure of encounter also draws an abrasive picture, addressed to its time, of sort of first forced dialogue that generates numbers for censuses. Anti-censuses, in definition proposed here, are artistic works that drive beyond or work against current operating assumptions about enumeration, and that expose aesthetics of what we take to be nonaesthetic counting procedures. They push to repicture the counting scene as a format of its time. They often use surprise genres and materials to jar, even .jeer at, and upset received terms of ongoing intellectual debate about population (though not with a sentimentally anti-statistical stance or fear of number). Wordsworth's multigeneric power here is to combine ballad, numbering- or census-scene, and scene of forced speech. To complicate first definition of further, works in this mode also, if worth their salt, take into account, through unexpected tonal organization, that oppositional counting is an office of rebellion assigned artists. When anti-census is done specifically by poetry, so that it allegorizes its own metrical condition as an alternative numerical case from which to criticize what we would now call (the word is extremely anachronistic for Wordsworth) demographic measures practiced in real world, air of plaint or resistance it puts on often sounds rote and sentimental. Some shared melancholy, though they are very different poems, about prefabricated element of their own protesting offices, for instance, was also formal and tonal under-problem for two of most famous eighteenth-century poems, Gray's Elegy Written in a Country Churchyard and Goldsmith's The Deserted Village. Their pathos lies not only in theme of depopulation but in their assignment to remeasure it. Part of their effective pathos was in managing, as undercurrent, to ironize and lament their own controlled and rationalized meters. …