Virtuosity as a Performance Concept: A Philosophical Analysis.

V. A. Howard

Philosophy of Music Education Review · 1997 · 32 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

able slow motion sequence, a mother cheetah is shown in hot pursuit of a hare, her young cubs gambolling about, getting in the way. The hare darts hither and yon, totally befuddling the cubs but not the mother. Head down, eyes fixed on the prey she follows its every move, twisting her long body in mid-air to adjust to the hare's desperate zigzags. Finally, after a chase made longer by the cubs' interference, she pounces on the unfortunate hare. Settling back on her haunches to catch her breath, she looks about to check on the whereabouts of her cubs. (There are lions in the area.) Suddenly, the hare squeezes out from under her in a miraculous escape and bounds off. In that moment, as if one with the motion of the hare itself, she wheels about and in a final burst of speed and agility snatches the hare in her jaws killing it instantly. There! I cried out at the screen. 'There is one of nature's great virtuoso performances complete with a momentary lapse quickly corrected. But then, Is it? I asked myself in th0 next breath. Acceptable as a metaphoric descrip'^ tion of the cheetah's behavior, what is missing here that disqualifies her behavior from literally being a virtuoso (or virtuosa) performance? Indeed, from being a performance of any kind? Reflection, I thought. The cheetah does not sit back on her haunches and say to herself, Well, that was just fine. Oops! Get that hare. Damn, I'll try to do better next time. Nor are other cheetahs applauding from the sidelines and commenting on the momentary lapse as a mere fluff in an otherwise exemplary performance (like Rubenstein striking the occasional wrong note). She lacks a discerning audience as well as reflective self criticism. Nor, again literally, could she be said to express anything meaningful in or about her situation; for the latter requires a symbolic medium to occur. The cheetah behaves in a context of pursuit and capture that is largely instinctive even if partly learned, as her cubs were learning. She behaves neither in a context of symbolic meaning-making and interpretation nor to a field of critical peers ready to pass judgement for posterity in a way that might enshrine a new standard of pursuit and capture for future cheetah generations. However hard wired she may be to behave in certain ways, no score or script directs her behavior. She strives for no standard, just the hare. She acts on signal but does not perform on cue. She is neither a virtuosa nor a