Pinch analysis : a state-of-the-art overview : Techno-economic analysis

B. Linnhoff

Process Safety and Environmental Protection · 1993 · 154 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

Through much of its fifteen year history Pinch Analysis has been somewhat controversial. Early on, as Pinch Technology, it introduced simple concepts in a field and an era otherwise known for complex mathematical methods. Reports from first industrial applications claimed design improvements so large as to invite incredulity. Moreover, Pinch Analysis was commercialized early in its development when there was little know-how from practical application. This led to several commercial failures and many vested interests. To this day, opinions remain divided. Morgan (M. W. Kellog) reports that Pinch Analysis significantly improves both the process design and the design process. Steinmeyer (Monsanto) is concerned that Pinch Analysis may miss out on ... major opportunity for improvement.... As is often the case when there is a difference of opinion, different parties have different data. Some of the concepts of Pinch Analysis are widely known, others are less well known. Experience with practical application varies. Some organizations have successfully integrated the approach into the design process, others rely on one or two technical experts. In addition, Pinch Analysis has undergone evolution making it difficult for the casual observer to come to an up-to-date assessment. It has evolved from the design of heat exchanger networks into a general methodology for the design of integrated systems ranging from processes to Total Sites. We attempt to give a state-of-the-art overview. It gives a summary of key established concepts with special emphasis on those concepts which are less well known than others. This is followed by a description of eight recent developments. Some of these developments sharpen the focus of the established concepts, others widen the scope. All of them follow the established pattern of Pinch Analysis of setting targets prior to design. The eight developments are: Pressure Drop Optimization; Multiple Base Case Design; Distillation Column Profiles; Low Temperature Process Design; Batch Process Integration; Water and Waste Water Minimization; Total Site Integration; and Emissions Targeting. We concentrate on the essence not the detail. Case studies are described and scope and impact of practical applications are assessed. For details of methodology, the reader is referred to the relevant references. To complete the overview, we provide a comprehensive summary of previous literature. Theory and applications are covered, and a historical perspective is given. The evolution of Pinch is discussed and it is argued that the term Pinch Analysis is more appropriate today that Pinch Technology. Pinch Analysis is used for the scoping and screening of options during targeting prior to design. The choice of utilities, capital cost optimization, changes in the process/reactor/separation system, overall process emissions, etc. are all avaluated prior to design i.e. in analysis mode