Gulf and Caribbean Research · 2003 · 29 citations · 23 references
Life SciencesConservation BiologyEcologyConservation EthicsMarine ConservationMarine EcologyEnvironmental EthicsMarine Conservation EcologyMarine Conservation PolicyMarine Ecosystem ManagementMarine Resource ManagementAttitudes Toward Marine ConservationMarine Environmental EthicsMarine Resource SustainabilityNo-take Marine ReservesNo-take ReservesProductive CapabilitiesResource Conservation EthicsRestoration Of Marine Ecosystems
Different human expectations and environmental ethics are key factors preventing the creation of marine reserve networks. People are skeptical about the benefits of no-take marine reserves because they have adjusted to scarcity and have low expectations about the productive capability of marine ecosystems. Pauly (1995) described this as a shifting baseline in which each generation sets its expectations based on its direct experiences and discounts experiences of previous generations. I show evidence of a declining Caribbean baseline based on Nassau grouper landings from Cuba and the U.S., and review common and often conflicting types of conservation ethics existing in North America. No-take marine reserves can help reestablish human expectations about resource productivity by restoring past conditions in places. Leopold’s biotic ethic provides a framework for achieving sustainable resource use based on laws of ecology and human self-interest. Because changing expectations usually requires direct local experience, education, and changes in conservation ethics, implementing successful marine reserve networks will probably be a slow, incremental process. Establishing no-take reserves can help restore human expectations and provide a common basis for conservation by providing a window to the past and a vision for the future.
23
Daniel Pauly, Villy Christensen, Anne Johanne Tang Dalsgaard et al. · Science · 1998 · 4.7K citations
Anecdotes and the shifting baseline syndrome of fisheries
Daniel Pauly · Trends in Ecology & Evolution · 1995 · 2.5K citations
Entering the Century of the Environment: A New Social Contract for Science
Jane Lubchenco · Science · 1998 · 1.3K citations
Effects of Marine Reserves on Adjacent Fisheries
Callum M. Roberts, James A. Bohnsack, Fiona Gell et al. · Science · 2001 · 986 citations