College and university · 2007 · 29 citations · 0 references
Social SciencesSociologyAmerican PoliticsAmerican StudiesSocial InequalityDemographic DividendIntergenerational PolicyAmerican DreamMiddle Class HistoryMiddle-class AdvantageYoung Adulthood
Strapped: Why America's 20- and 30-Somethings Can't Get Ahead BY TAMARA DRAUT DOUBLEDAY, 2005. 237 PP. Reviewed by Travis Reindl It's an argument almost as old as time itself - the exchange of anecdotes and accusations between and among generations about who has had a tougher go of it, and who is responsible for that state of affairs. In Strapped, analyst and commentator Tamara Draut pushes beyond the I walked school uphill both ways storyline with a data-rich indictment of the market practices and public policies that are hobbling the nation's 20- and 30-somethings in their pursuit of the American Dream. Buttressed by stories of struggling young adults, it offers a sobering assessment of our human capital pipeline. Ultimately, though, it misses the boat on several crucial points, leaving this analyst (and 30-something) a little cold. Draut hits the mark in outlining the convergence of forces that threaten the middle class prospects of Generation X and the Millennials. Rapidly rising educational costs and expectations are creating a new debtor class of Americans, who rack up five- and six-figure financial obligations before they even leave home. The New Economy's labor market, which prizes speed over stability, hazes a growing number of its newest entrants and diverts them into temporary work unrelated their training. Deregulation of industries such as mortgage and credit card lending has given rise practices that target the cash-poor and keep them that way. Government retrenchment has weakened the social safety net, from student aid childcare housing. Through glimpses into the lives of young Americans from a wide variety of backgrounds and circumstances, the book puts a face on the numbers that many policymakers and analysts know all too well. The reader is introduced Carolyn, a teacher, and Ryan, a police officer, trying make ends meet, a task complicated by the struggle secure quality, affordable daycare for their two young sons. For Jerome and Wanda, the economic and professional promise of obtaining master's degrees dissolved into stress and frustration in the face of a layoff and prolonged unemployment. Clayton's story is one of a high school guidance counselor and single parent juggling daily expenses with college savings for his children and payment of his own school debt. These are more than hard luck vignettes - they are a warning that working hard and playing by the rules may not be enough in the system we are building. Unfortunately, Draut is her own worst enemy, both anecdotally and analytically. She undercuts her portrait of an increasingly Darwinian transition adulthood with stories of people whose situations are as much the product of poor choices and skewed priorities as they are of unfavorable circumstances. Elaine, for example, finds herself $40,000 in credit card debt, but feels that having new furniture, a trip Europe, and the ideal wedding has been worth the price. In the case of David and Lisa, building the 40i(k), flying crosscountry family events, and finding a home that enables their toddlers have separate bedrooms rivals paying off $40,000 in credit card debt on the to do list. …