Revolutionary and Operatic Models for the Funeral March of the Eroica Symphony

Richard Burke

˜The œBeethoven newsletter · 2004 · 16 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

I. The THE FUNERAL MARCH AS A FUNCTIONAL PIECE HAS A LONG AND LARGELY UNTRACEABLE HISTORY. Handbooks of military music and accounts of funeral ceremonies suggest that the earliest marches were sometimes nothing more than a slow regular beat on a large drum. Sometimes, when a corps of drummers played, their instruments were draped in black crepe, not only for the symbolic significance of the color but also for the effect on the sound. This still happens today at some state funerals. The cloth covering softens the attack, creating a diffuse thud. The effect is mournful, even ominous, and it produces a beat that is a bit less assertive than that of an ordinary march. After all, no one expects mourners in a cortege to walk in time to the music. The sound of the muffled drum, then, is the feature around which the funeral march developed, and the march's gloomy, relentless pulse remained its most characteristic trait. When other instruments were added, they did little to change the overall effect. In the earliest extant funeral marches, instrumental parts seem only to emphasize the stasis of the march and the weight of its beat. The four trumpets in Purcell s Funeral for Queen Mary, for example, play nothing but sustained chord progressions. Even Handel's famous Dead March from Saul, a rare major key example, has a somber, inert solemnity about it. Paradoxically, even though the participants and the instrumentalists in a funeral procession move forward, the music that propels them seems to stand in place. By the time funeral marches began to appear in dramatic works of the middle of the eighteenth century, they had developed some fairly predictable features. The monotony of a simple, steady dotted rhythm had replaced that of the muffled drum. The tunes were simple and minor keys prevailed. Unlike contemporary military or coronation marches, they were short pieces, sometimes a mere eight measures long. Despite their brevity, these marches managed to create static music with a grave, dignified tone. Perhaps the finest of these is from Giuseppe Sarti's Giulio Sabino from 1781. Sarti, student of Padre Martini and teacher of Luigi Cherubini, was one of the most famous and highly respected composers of Italian opera in the second half of the eighteenth century. His march, like many examples of the genre, begins with no introduction (Example 1). The phrases are short and concise, and end in a characteristic cadential figure, a falling interval leading to a punctuating dotted rhythm (mm. 2 and 4). The dynamics offer some contrast, but the harmony is simple and changes slowly. An occasional running upbeat figure, as at the end of m. 2, suggests the roll of a drum. These same features, found in many of the marches of Sard's day, would become defining characteristics of the genre.' In the nineteenth century, the funeral march began to make its way into symphonies, sonatas, sets of variations, and other instrumental works. These marches sound very much like their operatic counterparts, but they have become character pieces, no longer meant to accompany a funeral cortege. In the first few decades of the nineteenth century, some of these marches-in a sense, completing a circle-became functional works again, when they moved from the concert hall back to the cemetery and the public square. Even today, two of the three marches that most clearly typify the genre are from pianoforte sonatas by Beethoven and Chopin.2 Both achieve their static motion and mournful tone through the same basic features as eighteenth-century operatic marches. But the third of the three, the one from the Eroica Symphony, is different in a number of striking ways. Its individuality is often ascribed to Beethoven's encounter with the music of the French Revolution. II. Beethoven and Republican Music The difference between music written by French composers before and after the Revolution can be seen in the work of Francois-Joseph Gossec. …