Networks and states: the global politics of Internet governance

Unknown author(s)

Choice Reviews Online · 2011 · 345 citations · 3 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The Internet’s transnational scope and scale challenge the traditional territorial monopoly of state power, yet filtering, censorship, and cyber‑security concerns suggest it may ultimately be subordinated to nation‑states. Mueller argues that Internet governance creates a global politics and new transnational institutions. Using networked governance theory, he traces the evolution of Internet governance from ICANN to the World Summit on the Information Society, the Internet Governance Forum, and national controls, illustrating the unique challenges of peer‑to‑peer and critical resource regulation. He identifies four conflict areas—intellectual property, cyber‑security, content regulation, and control of domain names/IP addresses—that generate a global politics, and shows that emerging transnational institutions could foster global governance of communication‑information policy.

Abstract

When the prevailing system of governing divides the planet into mutually exclusive territorial monopolies of force, what institutions can govern the Internet, with its transnational scope, boundless scale, and distributed control? Given filtering-censorship by states and concerns over national cyber-security, it is often assumed that the Internet will inevitably be subordinated to the traditional system of nation-states. In Networks and States, Milton Mueller counters this, showing how Internet governance poses novel and fascinating governance issues that give rise to a global politics and new transnational institutions. Drawing on theories of networked governance, Mueller provides a broad overview of Internet governance from the formation of ICANN to the clash at the World Summit on the Information Society (WSIS), the formation of the Internet Governance Forum, the global assault on peer-to-peer file sharing and the rise of national-level Internet control and security concerns. Mueller identifies four areas of conflict and coordination that are generating a global politics of Internet governance: intellectual property, cyber-security, content regulation, and the control of critical Internet resources (domain names and IP addresses). He investigates how recent theories about networked governance and peer production can be applied to the Internet, offers case studies that illustrate the Internet's unique governance problems, and charts the historical evolution of global Internet governance institutions, including the formation of a transnational policy network around the WSIS. Internet governance has become a source of conflict in international relations. Networks and States explores the important role that emerging transnational institutions could play in fostering global governance of communication-information policy.

References

3