The Short- and Long-term Effects of a Handbook on Antimicrobial Prescribing Patterns of Hospital Physicians

Abstract

Abstract This study evaluates the effect of a specially designed, physician-oriented handbook of antimicrobial use on the prescribing patterns of a group of 50 doctors at a university hospital. Data were evaluated over a period of one-and-one-half years, before and after the distribution of the handbook. For the purposes of this study, antimicrobial therapy was classified: 1) inappropriate if it violated one of a number of recognized principles of antimicrobial therapy, 2) appropriate if it agreed with specific recommendations or alternatives given in the distributed reference handbook, and 3) acceptable if it was neither inappropriate nor appropriate as defined by the handbook. An initial survey of antimicrobial prescribing patterns was made. Five months later the handbook was distributed. A two-week orientation program, consisting of the distribution and promotion of the problem-oriented, pocket-sized handbook of appropriate antimicrobial therapy, was conducted. The handbook, which was developed by the authors and reviewed and approved by a panel of infectious disease specialists, presented guidelines for appropriate and efficacious usage of antimicrobial agents as most currently accepted in common clinical infections. Subsequent surveys were then conducted two weeks, three months, and six months after distribution of the handbook. A statistically significant difference ( p <0.01) in antimicrobial prescribing patterns was noted between the survey conducted two weeks after the introduction of the handbook and the other surveys. In this survey, while therapy classified inappropriate decreased from 45% to 28%, therapy considered appropriate as recommended increased from 33% to 53%. The findings of this study demonstrated that the introduction and promotion of the handbook decreased abuse and increased proper use of antimicrobial therapy, although the effect is sustainable for only a short duration—no longer than three months. These results indicate the need for a vigorous, updated program to achieve and maintain current appropriate antibiotic therapy in clinical medicine.