Choice Reviews Online · 2006 · 211 citations · 0 references
HumanitiesHistoryMedieval StudiesMedieval HistoryMedieval LiteratureMedieval PhilosophyFrench Literary TheoryMedieval FranceMedieval French LiteratureMedieval HistoriographyMiddle AgesAmalgamationFeudal CritiqueMedieval Literary GenresPostwar French LiteraturePostwar French SocietySociological Criticism
The Premodern Condition shows that leading critical theorists have a surprising affinity for medievalism, continually mining the medieval epoch for philosophical vocabularies, social formations, and systems of thought. Holsinger seeks to reconceive French nouvelle critique discourses as a brilliant amalgamation of medievalisms. He draws on a wide range of philosophical, literary‑critical, and sociological works from the 1960s French nouvelle critique and supplements the thesis with newly translated essays by Bataille and Bourdieu that illustrate medievalism’s persistence. The book demonstrates that medievalism is one of the most significant epiphenomena of postwar French thought, making it an important touchstone for specialists in medieval studies and critical theory.
The Premodern Condition identifies and explains a surprising affinity for medievalism and medieval studies among the leading figures of critical theory. Drawing on a wide range of philosophical, literary-critical, and sociological works produced within the French nouvelle critique of the 1960s, Holsinger argues for reconceiving these discourses, in part, as a brilliant amalgamation of medievalisms. Holsinger shows that the preoccupation with medieval cultures and practices among Bataille, Derrida, Lacan, Barthes, Bourdieu, and their cohorts was so wide ranging that it merits recognition as one of the most significant epiphenomena of postwar French thought. Not simply an object of nostalgic longing or an occasional source of literary exempla, the medieval epoch was continually mined by these thinkers for specific philosophical vocabularies, social formations, and systems of thought. To supplement its master thesis, The Premodern Condition also contains original essays by Bataille and Bourdieu - translated here for the first time into English - that testify in various ways to the strange persistence of medievalisms in French postwar avant-garde writings. What results is an important and original work that will be a touchstone for specialists in medieval studies and critical theory alike.