The Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology (1973-) · 1979 · 36 citations · 0 references
LawCriminal LawCriminologyCriminal ProcedureJudicial PoliticsJudicial ReviewCriminal JusticeCriminal Justice PolicyCriminal Justice SystemsEmpirical Study Of CourtsPlea BargainingAdversary ModelCourt WorkloadCriminal Justice PoliticsJudicial Decision-making WorkloadJudicial Resource AllocationJudicial Workload Allocation
In the past several years there has been a growing controversy over the impact of caseload pressure upon the processing of criminal defendants. In traditional criminal justice research, pervasive dysfunctioning in the criminal courts system has been attributed largely to caseload pressure. Some criminal justice scholars, however, have recently questioned the central role accorded caseload pressure and have supported their arguments with empirical evidence. While these recent studies suffer from certain shortcomings, the questions which they raise are extremely important and timely. Furthermore, these studies have significant implications for both theory and policy. The demise of caseload pressure as a central concept in the study of criminal courts would leave a large gap in our theoretical understanding of how these units function. If caseload pressures do not account for high dismissal rates, pervasive plea bargaining, and the weakening of the adversary system, what does? The policy implications of this controversy are just as significant. If increasing court resources-which decrease caseload pressures-will not significantly improve the operations of criminal courts, what will?