The Yale Law Journal · 1988 · 25 citations · 1 references
LawConstitutional LawPolitical ScienceConstitutional HistoryConstitutional TheoryPolitical HistoryComparative Constitutional TheoryConstitutional CritiqueHistory Of Political TheoryDeliberative PoliticsDeliberative ReasoningRepublican TheoryRepublican Thought
sketch out their respective modern visions of republicanism in both constitutional law and political theory.In this brief comment it is impossible to address the many issues that they raise, or to follow each author down the many byways that he chooses to travel.But it is both possible and important to isolate several themes, recurrent in both pieces, that seem central to their conception of modern republicanism.These themes, when fully understood, point out the serious weaknesses of modern republicanism as a comprehensive political theory.The overall conclusion can be stated very quickly.No political theory can concentrate on process and deliberation to the exclusion of substantive concerns.Yet that is precisely what Michelman and Sunstein heroically try to do.The different parts of this essay in their separate ways all pursue their failure to come to grips with the substantive components of republicanism.The first section explores the extent to which Michelman and Sunstein can separate the procedural and deliberative elements of modern republicanism from the substantive and controversial outlook of the classical republican writers.The second section turns to a comparison of republicanism, as both Michelman and Sunstein reconstruct it, and its nemesis, interest group pluralism.I argue that both Michelman and Sunstein oversimplify the opposition because they do not draw sufficient distinctions between the normative and descriptive accounts of the pluralist position.This failure in turn leads them to dismiss, with scarcely a mention, the theories that have a Lockean emphasis on limited government and private property.In the third section I suggest that these theories offer a superior response to the pluralist nightmare Sunstein and Michelman describe.While both men praise the virtues of deliberation, they do not give us any guidance as to the form that deliberation should take or the ends that it should seek.Quite the opposite, as I argue in the fourth section, they only t
1
Nuisance Law: Corrective Justice and Its Utilitarian Constraints
Richard A. Epstein · The Journal of Legal Studies · 1979 · 127 citations
Law, Jurisprudence, Public Law +15