Acting the Lover: Gender and Desire in Narratives of Passing Women

Theresa Braunschneider

˜The œEighteenth century/˜The œeighteenth century (Lubbock, Tex. Online) · 2004 · 11 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

In the mid-eighteenth century, British presses issued a considerable number of prose narrative accounts of women who disguise themselves in men's clothing and convincingly pass as men. Marked with the generic label of a history, life, or and told in either the first or third person, these texts purport to narrate the stories of historical women living as men in contemporary or recent England, Scotland, Ireland, or continental Europe. Often celebrating their heroines as bold adventurers, occasionally censuring them as villains or even monsters, these passing women narratives commemorate such figures as Hannah Snell, who served as James Gray in both the army and navy and became famous for performing her military exercises in uniform on the stage at Sadler's Wells; Christian Davies, an Irish gentlewoman who married her servant and then went to war in search of him when he was conscripted, only to discover her own martial Inclination and continue as a soldier after she gave up the search; Jenny Cameron, rebellious daughter turned passing woman turned undisguised soldier who became a central figure in the mythology of the Jacobite cause in Scotland; Anne Bonny and Mary Read, pirates who first fall for each other while disguised and then become fast friends after revealing to one another their true sex; Charlotte Charke, entrepreneur, actress, and daughter of Colley Cibber, who embarrassed her family by intermittently dressing as a man and then publishing her autobiography; Elizabeth Ogden, the Female Porter of Shoreditch, who traveled around England in search of work and women to woo; the unnamed apothecary's an Englishwoman who left her and adopted the persona of a wealthy man to seek marriage with another woman and whose narrative is told in the Remarks following the English translation of the history of Catharine Vizzani (the cross-dressing Italian adventurer whose passionate and oft-indulged desire for Ladies gains her the suspicion of being a hermaphrodite); and the female husband Mary Hamilton, who was arrested and whipped for marrying a series of women while passing as a man.1Despite the ostensibly wide range of subjects represented here, and despite these texts' frequent claims that their heroine's behavior is unique, these narratives have key components in common, and the figure of the passing woman emerges from this body of writing as highly conventionalized and codified, with several key plot and character elements echoing between texts.2 Here, I draw attention to one particular element that these prose narratives share: each of their title characters while passing as a man becomes erotically engaged with other women, either actively courting one or more, or finding herself (quite happily) the object of one or more women's erotic attention. In addition, unlike most of the warrior women of contemporaneous popular balladry, who follow a male lover to war and then follow him home to be his wife, and unlike women who temporarily disguise themselves as men in a novelistic or dramatic subplot (e.g., Violetta in Eliza Haywood's Love in Excess or Angelica in George Farquhar's Sir Harry Wildair), these prose narratives either lack or exceed a structuring heterosexual narrative. That is, these are not women who take on men's dress simply to follow a or lover and whose narrative then concludes with the happy heterosexual closure of reconciliation or marriage. Rather, each of these prose narratives provides an alternative to that model, either by discussing the woman's cross-dressing outside of any relation to a or male lover, by explaining the passing as a way to escape a cruel husband, or by creating a heroine who originally disguises her sex to pursue a but grows to relish manly adventures for their own sake. Moreover, these narratives tend to be structured episodically, moving the character through a relatively unpredictable, logically unconnected series of adventures-a narrative structure that attests to these texts' relative investment in character over plot. …