Asian Folklore Studies · 2000 · 75 citations · 31 references
ArtsAnthropologyReligionHindu StudiesHistory Of ReligionsPhilosophy Of ReligionHindu HistoryHinduismSacred EcologiesSacred TextsHindu Environmental ThoughtMaterialist ValuesSacred Anthropology
This essay revisits a debate that took place in the social sciences over the sacred-cow controversy for the purpose of ecological musing. The debate was stimulated largely by Marvin Harris, whose cultural materialist position reduced the symbolism of the cow in Hinduism to a set of irrational beliefs. His alternative was to see the cow's sacredness in terms of a calculus of calories. Needless to say, his work led to criticism from both anthropologists and humanists. In the first part of the paper, I trace the history of the controversy, then move on to consider the cow herself from a Hindu point of view. Finally, I conclude with some theoretical remarks about the need for scholars of religion to be sensitive to both texts and contexts by blurring the theoretical boundaries between the fields of religion and anthropology.
31
The Dialogic Imagination: Four Essays
Edward Wasiolek, M. M. Bakhtin, Michael Holquist et al. · Comparative Literature · 1982 · 7.6K citations
Social Space and Symbolic Power
Pierre Bourdıeu · Sociological Theory · 1989 · 4.3K citations
Homo Hierarchicus: The Caste System and Its Implications.
Gerald D. Berreman, Louis Dumont · Man · 1971 · 2.3K citations
Sherry B. Ortner · American Anthropologist · 1973 · 775 citations