Marginalization Paradoxes in Bayesian and Structural Inference

Abstract

Summary We describe a range of routine statistical problems in which marginal posterior distributions derived from improper prior measures are found to have an unBayesian property—one that could not occur if proper prior measures were employed. This paradoxical possibility is shown to have several facets that can be successfully analysed in the framework of a general group structure. The results cast a shadow on the uncritical use of improper prior measures. A separate examination of a particular application of Fraser's structural theory shows that it is intrinsically paradoxical under marginalization.