American Philosophical Quarterly · 2024 · 18 citations · 18 references
HumanitiesPhilosophyAestheticsConceptual ArtVisual CommunicationAesthetic EvaluationAesthetic ExperienceAesthetic JudgmentAesthetic PerceptionAesthetic TheoryAesthetic ValueAesthetic AppraisalAesthetic CognitionAesthetic ExpertiseAesthetic Understanding
Abstract I propose a new account of the limits of aesthetic testimony. One of this new account's main claims is that, among the kinds of aesthetic cognitive achievements, it is useful to distinguish aesthetic understanding. In particular, I suggest that the aesthetic understanding of X involves an understanding of why X is aesthetically valuable. In turn, aesthetic understanding is essentially connected to the deployment of aesthetic concepts. Given the fine-grained structure of some of these concepts, certain forms of testimony are not adequate to acquire them.
18
How to Be a Pessimist about Aesthetic Testimony
Robert Hopkins · The Journal of Philosophy · 2011 · 221 citations · Full text
Having Concepts: a Brief Refutation of the Twentieth Century
Jerry A. Fodor · Mind & Language · 2004 · 214 citations
M. Budd · The British Journal of Aesthetics · 2003 · 163 citations