Comparison of branch-point detection approaches using a Shack–Hartmann wavefront sensor

Abstract

Two methods for identifying branch points from Shack–Hartmann wavefront sensor (SHWFS) measurements were studied: the circulation of phase gradients approach and the beam-spread approach. These approaches were tested using a simple optical-vortex model, with wave-optics simulations, and with experimental data. It was found that these two approaches are synergistic regarding their abilities to detect branch points. Specifically, the beam-spread approach works best when the branch point is located toward the center of the SHWFS’s lenslet pupil, whereas the circulation of phase gradients approach works best when the branch point is located toward the edge of the SHWFS’s lenslet pupil. These behaviors were observed studying the simple optical-vortex model; however, they were further corroborated with the wave-optics and experimental results. The developments presented support researchers studying high scintillation optical-turbulence environments and inform efforts in developing branch-point tolerant reconstruction algorithms.