Phylotaxonomic assessment based on four core gene sets and proposal of a genus definition among the families Paracoccaceae and Roseobacteraceae

Abstract

The families Paracoccaceae and Roseobacteraceae comprise metabolically, phenotypically and genotypically diverse members, and their descriptions rely heavily on 16S rRNA gene analysis. Hundreds of genera have been reported within the two families and misclassifications have been a reoccurring problem, even when the taxonomies have been established based on genome-scale phylogenetic reconstructions. In this study, we conducted a comprehensive phylotaxonomic assessment of the families Paracoccaceae and Roseobacteraceae based on four ubiquitous gene sets, bac120 (120 genes in Bacteria), rhodo268 (268 genes in ‘ Rhodobacteraceae ’, defined in this study), rp1 (16 ribosomal protein genes in Prokaryote) and rp2 (23 ribosomal protein genes in Prokaryote), using two tree-inferring applications and two approaches (supermatrix and consensus). The results suggested that the four supermatrix trees based on bac120 and rhodo268 shared a high proportion of common nodes (>88.4 %) and the topology was reproducible among all the trees within most of the genera. The evolutionary distance (ED) analysis showed significant overlapping between the intergeneric and intrageneric comparisons, implying that the proposal of some genera seemed to be unnecessary. In addition, the bac120 gene set and the FastTree program were found to be the most cost-effective way to conduct phylogenomic analysis of the families Paracoccaceae and Roseobacteraceae . An ED threshold of 0.21–0.23 based on either bac120 or rhodo268 was proposed as one standard for later genus delimitation in these families. A comprehensive phylogenetic framework is presented in this study and the proposed genus definition will help to establish a more reasonable taxonomy in the families Paracoccaceae and Roseobacteraceae .