The Cormac McCarthy Journal · 2023 · 14 citations · 0 references
HumanitiesLiteratureBritish LiteratureEnglish LiteratureFictionAutobiographical WritingRomance FictionAppalachian LiteratureBiographical HermeneuticsNovel Writing
Known most notably for her previous book on McCarthy’s early work, Reading the World (2009), Dianne Luce has undertaken a project that is, even by her lofty standards, daunting. In Embracing Vocation, Luce has set out to write a biographically informed history of McCarthy’s “writing life.” What is so challenging about this project is the dearth of reliable biographical information; we simply do not know many details about his personal life. What we think we know often has a couple of different iterations, like the old Appalachian folktales he so clearly adored. Relying on archived correspondence, personal interviews, and multiple drafts of the novels, this book seeks to provide a largely professional biography of McCarthy’s early career.The book is divided into three parts, which correspond to McCarthy’s first three novels, The Orchard Keeper (1965), Outer Dark (1968), and Child of God (1973). These parts are structured around what Luce calls McCarthy’s “writing processes—the genesis, composition, editing, and revision” of these novels (viii). Each part concludes with sales information and reviews of the work, material that is not new to McCarthy scholars, but efficiently gathered here. While it is divided into these three parts, in many ways the book feels as if it is defined by two main stages in McCarthy’s career. The first section details the extensive revision and editing of The Orchard Keeper, as McCarthy learns about novel writing, working with editors, and the business of literature. Luce takes us through several drafts of the book, reconstructing in rich detail the correspondence between McCarthy and his two Random House editors, first associate editor Lawrence Bensky and then his longtime editor Albert Erskine. We see McCarthy wrestling in this correspondence with suggestions from the editorial staff. Many of the editors’ concerns are ones that will be familiar to today’s readers; for example, they made suggestions that McCarthy name and identify his characters more often, posed queries about the accuracy and necessity of regional vernacular and archaic terminology, and initiated discussions about the aesthetic merits of his idiosyncratic punctuation. At one point, Erskine (William Faulkner’s longtime editor as well) suggests that McCarthy’s atypical punctuation might suggest too heavily the influence of Faulkner, rather than “a style of your own” (55). We see, through Luce’s painstaking reconstruction of these exchanges, that McCarthy was generally open to editorial input with this first novel.The next two parts of Embracing Vocation demonstrate McCarthy’s gained experience and knowledge about the novel-writing business. They contain fewer details about the give-and-take with editors, as apparently there was less of this correspondence, and these parts more closely follow McCarthy’s own revisions from draft to draft of the novels. In these parts Luce’s meticulous research and considerable abilities to synthesize vast amounts of information give us a much more complex engagement with the archives and drafting process than we have seen before. As the book explores McCarthy’s second and third novels, the reader can see the young writer growing in confidence in his craft and his vision for his fictive worlds, more able to articulate his artistic visions, and more comfortable in rejecting editorial suggestions with which he disagrees.Part of what is so rewarding about this book is that it allows us to consider just how different McCarthy’s treasured books might have been without editorial intervention and McCarthy’s own rethinking of the projects as they were being developed. We learn, for example, that the character of the vindictive Mildred in Orchard Keeper only becomes insistent that John Wesley avenge his father’s death in the final draft. We also learn that in early drafts Sylder confesses to John Wesley that he killed his father and that John Wesley discovers his father’s bones. Luce uncovers a gem in McCarthy’s correspondence with his early editor Bensky when he explains Arthur Ownby’s rebellious ways: rather than seeing Ownby as a “bombthrowing anarchist,” he is, in McCarthy’s words, “an amiable anarchist” (88). We learn that Culla’s story in Outer Dark originally contained substantially more interiority, especially regarding Culla’s sense of guilt over his treatment of Rinthy and his abandonment of his child. To this end, McCarthy initially conceived of the Triune as a symbolic manifestation of Culla’s conflicted inner thoughts, modeled after Freud’s theory of the three-part psyche.Embracing Vocation demonstrates how McCarthy, through the drafting process, consistently tones down the grotesque elements of the decomposing bodies in Child of God, also removing the much more graphic scenes of necrophilia that appeared in early drafts. In early versions of this novel, Lester Ballard also castrates himself out of remorse and a desire to quell his murderous and necrophiliac impulses. Erskine prudently asked McCarthy to reconsider this clunky literal manifestation of Ballard’s moral struggles, and the scene did not appear in the final draft. Luce states that this kind of attention to the drafting process of his first three books creates “a multidimensional metatext to challenge and enlarge our readings of the published versions” (viii).Nearly all of the instances of revision that Luce outlines end up distancing the reader further from the inner thoughts of the central protagonists, leading to the detached perspective so central to McCarthy’s narrative style. These revisions also remove from the text passages that feel like obvious interior moralizing from the characters, making them more mysterious and ultimately more interesting subjects. Luce also compiles the unfortunate working titles of these novels—“Red Mountain,” “Toilers at the Kiln,” “Such Hawks, Such Hounds”—that would later be discarded for The Orchard Keeper. “The Harrow,” “Among Supplicants,” “Blue Widow,” and others would eventually give way to Outer Dark. One wonders if we would be talking about these books today if some of these scenes, descriptions, and titles remained in the final drafts. Time and time again, we see that the editing process, whether initiated by his editors or McCarthy himself, played an integral part in what we think of as hallmarks of McCarthy’s craft: moral ambiguity, lack of interior character motivation, an acceptance of the potential for readers’ confusion.One especially compelling discussion of McCarthy’s editing process is a prolonged examination of how many of the events and scenes in Child of God were originally conceived for Outer Dark, and that many of Lester’s key scenes were originally written for Culla. Luce explains that a large factor in the conception of Child of God emerged from McCarthy “having composed several scenes in the first draft of Outer Dark that he removed . . . and subsequently revised for Child of God, evidence of a compositional kinship and continuity between his more fabular novel of murder and his more realistic one, specifically between protagonists Culla Holme and Lester Ballard, both bereft of family, homeless, hunted, haunted, homicidal” (204).Readers of these novels will have no doubt noticed parallels between them, but it is fascinating to see just how much of Child of God began in Outer Dark. Luce also documents how McCarthy would often compose more-or-less random sketches of regional stories and voices, apparently at times without having places for them in his fiction, only later weaving them into the novels. Many readers of The Passenger (2022) comment on how much the book feels like a relatively disconnected pastiche of stories. Luce’s book suggests that this style may be more illustrative of McCarthy’s writing process throughout his entire career, rather than a late-career cleaning off his desk.Precisely because there has been so little concrete biographical information about McCarthy, Luce’s attempt to merge biography and archival research feels new. For example, Embracing Vocation traces McCarthy’s near constant struggles with finances early in his career, as he is continuously disappointed with sales and contracts, constantly inquiring about the possibilities of advances. Luce uses correspondence around these issues to consider to what extent these pressures affected McCarthy’s creative process. The most original moments in this book are Luce’s attempts to combine what feels like rather speculative biographical claims with interpretations of the texts themselves, or as entryways into understanding their motivation. For example, Luce suggests (without much evidence) that Ownby’s alienation in Orchard Keeper may have had an autobiographical basis: “It seems possible that as McCarthy’s newly fleshed out Ownby’s backstory, he was drawing on his own feelings about his failed relationship [with Lee Holleman McCarthy]” (42). Doubtlessly, Luce’s foray into speculative psychology will be helpful for some and a bit of a reach for others.I suspect that the level of detail that Embracing Vocation provides and the attention to the minutiae of McCarthy’s revision process of his lesser-known works might be more than most readers will care to read from cover to cover. However, I also feel confident that this book will become required reading for anyone working on these early novels. Much like Michael Lynn Crews’s Books Are Made Out of Books (a work that Luce mentions several times) has become a reference book for those conducting research on McCarthy’s literary influences, Embracing Vocation will become a go-to resource for those wanting to think about McCarthy’s literary vision, especially the early stages where he was experimenting with and refining his craft. The fact that the book is very thoroughly and expertly indexed will serve these researchers well.As Luce admits in the book’s preface, any attempt to write “biography” about McCarthy is challenging, considering the conflicting versions of much of his history and absence of even some of the most basic facts in his life: “I have accepted as a given that there is much about McCarthy’s personal life that we still cannot know” (viii). In her attempt to create a study that is biographical, if not “a conventional biography,” Luce makes liberal use while constructing her arguments of one of McCarthy’s own favorite words, “perhaps,” along with other signifiers of uncertainty, such as “likely” and “probably,” that fit the mood of McCarthy’s writing perfectly. Indeed, despite decades of tireless and profitable research, there is still much that Luce and the rest of us do not know about McCarthy’s life and writing habits. She states that her conclusions are “open to reinterpretation” as new information emerges (ix). In this sense, the spirit of conjecture or speculation becomes necessary when talking about his life and writing habits. This book proves what many in McCarthy scholarly circles have felt for a while: Dianne Luce has done more to put together the biographical pieces of McCarthy’s puzzle than any other scholar.