Grammar and Social Organization: Yes/No Interrogatives and the Structure of Responding

Geoffrey Raymond

American Sociological Review · 2003 · 336 citations · 39 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The study explores how yes/no questions and their responses reveal links between grammar and social organization. The authors analyze the basic response organization triggered by yes/no questions, then examine how this pattern is adapted in surveys, medical interviews, and courtroom cross‑examinations to serve institutional goals. The results illuminate how language is tailored for interaction and offer analytic tools for sociologists studying behavior, theory, institutions, and the practical effects of questioning across diverse settings.

Abstract

Connections between grammar and social organization are examined via one of the most pervasive practices of speaking used in talk-in-interaction: yes/no type interrogatives and the turns speakers build in response to them. This investigation is composed of two parts. The first analyzes a basic organization set in motion by yes/ no type interrogatives, describing a preference for type-conforming responses and its consequences. The second considers how this basic organization is shaped and simplified to accomplish institutionally specific goals in survey research, medical encounters, and courtroom cross-examinations, and what such manipulations reveal about these institutions. Together these findings deepen our understanding of how language is adapted to-and for-interaction, while providing analytic resources for a broad range of sociologists, whether they are engaged in the direct observation of human behavior, developing sociological theories of language, analyzing institutions and social organizations, or interested in the practical consequences of questioning in the myriad institutions that make use of this form.

References

39