The Journal of Asian Studies · 2023 · 16 citations · 0 references
Social SciencesEconomicsHistoryAsian StudiesDevelopment EconomicsEconomic HistoryAsian EconomiesChinese StudiesEast Asian StudiesModern ChinaChinese EconomyChinese Intellectual HistoryChinese SocietyGlobal Economic HistoryUniversity Of Cambridge
This landmark book is the most recent installment in the impressive array of economic histories by Cambridge University Press. The thirty-nine chapters across two volumes cover the period between the emergence of territorial states and urban economies in East Asia in the first millennium BCE and China's present-day bid to become the global leader in technology, international trade, and infrastructural development. The editors are suited to the task. Richard von Glahn's Economic History of China: From Antiquity to the Nineteenth Century (2016) laid the groundwork for the present project, particularly its first volume. Debin Ma's work on the institutional change and factors of economic growth in early modern China brings coherence to the second volume's coverage of the country's tortuous journey toward economic “modernity” from the mid-nineteenth to the early twenty-first century.By chance, The Cambridge Economic History of China came out exactly forty years after the two-volume historical survey of another major Asian economy, India (also by Cambridge University Press, 1982, 1983). It is justified to say that a synthesis of the recent scholarship of China's economic history has long been overdue. As a result, the editors faced the formidable task of consolidating a vast and dynamic field of knowledge that has recently been joined by environmental and intellectual historians, archaeologists, and Silk Road scholars. Unsurprisingly, the authors had to find a balance between comprehensive representation of issues and approaches and limitations of space. Some lacunae are inevitable. Perhaps the most evident one is the absence of chapters on Taiwan, Hong Kong, and overseas Chinese economies. The scholars of early China may also question the editors' decision not to engage the materials from the prehistoric and early dynastic periods.The book deserves credit for what it actually achieves: an authoritative account of the key themes in China's economic history, including agriculture and rural economy, state finance, monetary system, and foreign trade. These and other issues are explored across four historical eras corresponding to the book's four parts: from the late preimperial period (roughly 700–221 BCE) to 1000 CE (vol. 1, pt. 1), 1000 to 1800 (vol. 1, pt. 2), 1800–1950 (vol. 2, pt. 1), and 1950 to the present (vol. 2, pt. 2).Part 1 of the first volume consists of six chapters, the first of which surveys the archaeological evidence for the economic “revolution” during the late preimperial period. The remaining five chapters focus on the aspects of early imperial economy (Han through Tang dynasties), including agriculture and environment, state impact on the economy, money and markets, economic philosophy and political economy, and the Silk Road trade. Part 1 is followed by an interlude on the Tang-Song transition, one of the crucial historical watersheds that witnessed market expansion, disintegration of state institutions of social control, and the relocation of population and economic centers from the Central Plains of North China to the Yangzi Basin. Twelve chapters in part 2 deal with the maturation of China's market economy in the aftermath of this transition and address ecological and population change, public finance and political economy, law and property rights, rural and urban economies, the monetary system, commercial networks, foreign trade, and living standards.Part 1 of the second volume focuses on the period between 1800 and 1950. This is the longest of the book's four parts, accounted for by the centrality of “Great Divergence” debates in the Anglophone scholarship on Chinese economic history. Its fourteen chapters challenge the established narratives about the troubled first century of China's encounter with the modernizing West: supposedly declining living standards, resource depletion, incompetent leadership, and generally failed modernization policies. These authors reveal both the extraordinary vitality of traditional institutions and successful, if uneven, adoption of the new technologies and institutions in agriculture, industries, state enterprises, finance, business organization, trade and investment, transport, infrastructure, and education. Part 2 of the second volume is somewhat of an outlier, with chapters organized in a chronological rather than thematic order, tracing China's trajectory from the origins of communist institutions and radical socioeconomic experiments of the Mao Era (1949–76) through the period of market reforms (1978–early 2000s) to the revival of dirigiste policies in the wake of the global financial crisis of 2007–8.This reviewer has no doubt that the Cambridge Economic History of China will become a standard reference for economic historians, students, and general readers interested in the past of the world's second-largest economy. Each single chapter is a masterful piece of scholarship in its own right. Indeed, it is hard to imagine that anyone would read this book straight through. At the same time, the thematic continuities across the book's four parts encourage readers to explore various aspects of China's economy across time.