Representation in AI Evaluations

A. S. Bergman, Lisa Anne Hendricks, Maribeth Rauh, Boxi Wú, William S. Agnew, Markus Kunesch, Isabella Duan, Iason Gabriel, William Isaac

2023 · 17 citations · 35 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

Calls for representation in artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) are widespread, with "representation" or "representativeness" generally understood to be both an instrumentally and intrinsically beneficial quality of an AI system, and central to fairness concerns. But what does it mean for an AI system to be "representative"? Each element of the AI lifecycle is geared towards its own goals and effect on the system, therefore requiring its own analyses with regard to what kind of representation is best. In this work we untangle the benefits of representation in AI evaluations to develop a framework to guide an AI practitioner or auditor towards the creation of representative ML evaluations. Representation, however, is not a panacea. We further lay out the limitations and tensions of instrumentally representative datasets, such as the necessity of data existence and access, surveillance vs expectations of privacy, implications for foundation models and power. This work sets the stage for a research agenda on representation in AI, which extends beyond instrumentally valuable representation in evaluations towards refocusing on, and empowering, impacted communities.

References

35