Pension Reforms in Europe: How Far Have We Come and Gone?

Mauricio Soto, Alvar Kangur, Armand Fouejieu, Samuel Romero Martinez

Departmental Paper · 2021 · 112 citations · 30 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

In the past few decades, a myriad of reforms in Europe have had a significant impact on the way and extent to which public pensions provide retirement income.This departmental paper takes stock of where European pension systems stand and assesses their key characteristics.We present a novel measure of the balance between lifetime benefits and contributions-the Proportionality Measure-to examine pension systems' long-term sustainability, fairness, and intergenerational equity.The results presented in this paper suggest that in most countries additional efforts are needed to ensure the long-term sustainability of pension systems.Reforms enacted in recent decades raised retirement ages, streamlined benefit entitlements, and flattened the profile of pension spending projections.Still, in many countries, pension spending and deficits are projected to increase and remain at high levels for decades to come, fueled by rising old-age dependency.Older generations-that is, current retirees-receive lifetime benefits that exceed their lifetime contributions more than twofold.Reforms legislated in the decade following the GFC reduced the lifetime benefit-contribution ratio to nearly 1.5 for younger generations, going halfway toward long-term sustainability.However, subsequent and more recent reforms and reversals have partly eroded these gains and, as of 2021, the lifetime benefit-contribution ratio stands at about 1.7 for younger generations.This leaves most pension systems dependent on substantial state transfers for generations that crowd out other productive spending, including resources needed for greener and more inclusive economic transformation.Reforms have widened intergenerational divides, posing risks for broad support to pension systems in the future.To improve sustainability, reforms in most countries have more closely aligned contributions and benefits for younger cohorts who will not be treated as favorably as older ones.Compared to current retirees, future generations will access public pensions later xi ©International Monetary Fund.

References

30