Technical, Economic, and Environmental Comparison of Closed-Loop Recycling Technologies for Common Plastics

Taylor Uekert, Avantika Singh, Jason S. DesVeaux, Tapajyoti Ghosh, Arpit Bhatt, Geetanjali Yadav, Shaik Afzal, Julien Walzberg, Katrina M. Knauer, Scott Nicholson,

ACS Sustainable Chemistry & Engineering · 2023 · 381 citations · 29 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Over 400 million metric tons of plastic waste are generated annually worldwide, creating pollution and resource loss, yet quantitative data on recycling strategies’ capabilities and impacts remain scarce. The study develops a comprehensive dataset of material quality, retention, circularity, contamination tolerance, minimum selling price, GHG emissions, energy use, land use, toxicity, waste generation, and water use for closed‑loop polymer recycling technologies, covering mechanical recycling, solvent‑based dissolution, enzymatic hydrolysis, glycolysis, and vapor methanolysis of PET, PE, and PP. The authors identify electricity, steam, and organic solvents as the main contributors to performance metrics and use sensitivity and multicriteria decision analyses to pinpoint critical research priorities. Mechanical recycling and PET glycolysis achieve the lowest economic and environmental impacts, whereas dissolution, enzymatic hydrolysis, and methanolysis yield the highest recyclate quality, providing a quantitative baseline that enables reclaimers to select optimal end‑of‑life routes and assess future innovations.

Abstract

Over 400 million metric tons of plastic waste are generated globally each year, resulting in pollution and lost resources. Recycling strategies can recapture this wasted material, but there is a lack of quantitative and transparent data on the capabilities and impacts of these processes. Here, we develop a data set of material quality, material retention, circularity, contamination tolerance, minimum selling price, greenhouse gas emissions, energy use, land use, toxicity, waste generation, and water use metrics for closed-loop polymer recycling technologies, including mechanical recycling and solvent-based dissolution of polyethylene, polyethylene terephthalate (PET), and polypropylene, as well as enzymatic hydrolysis, glycolysis, and vapor methanolysis of PET. Mechanical recycling and PET glycolysis display the best economic (9%–73% lower than competing technologies) and environmental (7%–88% lower) performances, while dissolution, enzymatic hydrolysis, and methanolysis provide the best recyclate material qualities (2%–27% higher). We identify electricity, steam, and organic solvents as top process contributors to these metrics and apply sensitivity and multicriteria decision analyses to highlight key future research areas. The estimates derived in this work provide a quantitative baseline for comparing and improving recycling technologies, can help reclaimers identify optimal end-of-life routes for given waste streams, and serve as a framework for assessing future innovations.

References

29