Governing AI – attempting to herd cats? Introduction to the special issue on the Governance of Artificial Intelligence

Tim Büthe, Christian Djeffal, Christoph Lütge, Sabine Maasen, Nora von Ingersleben‐Seip

Journal of European Public Policy · 2022 · 54 citations · 59 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Artificial Intelligence raises both new and familiar governance challenges in novel ways, and its governance is already underway, characterized by the complex, unpredictable dynamics likened to herding cats. The essay introduces the contributions to the special issue, situating them in broader political and social science literatures. The essay sketches an interdisciplinary research agenda for AI governance. The essay highlights limits of explainable AI, argues for simultaneous consideration of AI ethics and governance, identifies underappreciated system effects, calls policymakers to weigh opportunities and risks, and suggests that focusing on AI abuses rather than the technology itself may offer a superior governance approach.

Abstract

Artificial Intelligence raises new, distinct governance challenges, as well as familiar governance challenges in novel ways. The governance of AI, moreover, is not an issue of distant futures, it is well underway – and it has characteristics akin to ‘herding cats’ with a mind of their own. This essay introduces the contributions to the special issue, situating them in broader political and social science literatures. It then provides a sketch of an interdisciplinary research agenda. It highlights the limits of 'explainable AI', makes the case for considering AI ethics and AI governance simultaneously, identifies as an underappreciated risk 'system effects' that arise from the introduction of AI applications, and calls for policymakers to consider both the opportunities and the risks of AI. Focusing on the (ab)uses of AI, rather than the complex, rapidly changing and hard-to-predict technology as such, might provide a superior approach to governing AI.

References

59