Economic Specialists and the Making of Chinese Economic Policy, 1955-1983.

Nina P. Halpern

Deep Blue (University of Michigan) · 1985 · 32 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

The dissertation investigates the allocation of policy making roles between Chinese generalists and economic specialists between 1955 and 1983. Through twelve case studies of economic policy making and examination of professional and institutional developments in the economics field, the study seeks the answers to three questions. First, what roles have the two groups played in the policy process? Second, what factors cause variation in specialists' participation and influence? Third, what types of linkages exist between and among specialists and generalists? The study finds that during the period specialists' role consisted most often of providing technical advice, although in 1958 and late 1964-74 specialists instead based their advice much more on political criteria, thus duplicating the role of generalists. Some evidence indicates that bureaucrats in China also articulate segmental interests, but probably less frequently than in Western democracies. However, another pattern identified in the U.S. was also found in China: Generalists are primarily responsible for determining what policy problems will be addressed, while specialists' role consists of providing possible solutions. The dissertation examines five hypothesized causes of variation in specialists' participation: the stage of development, the nature of the policy process, the context of policy making, the content of policy, and attributes of the specialists. The first is found to be related to changes in specialists' participation, but in a more complicated fashion than usually suggested. The second is only weakly related and the third unrelated to such variations. The fourth and fifth are found to be related, particularly strongly in the case of the fourth. The linkages discovered between and among specialists and generalists are primarily rational, or professional, rather than personal in nature. While formal bureaucratic linkages are very important, horizontal linkages between bureaucratic and academic specialists, both formal and informal, were discovered to be surprisingly strong. No evidence was discovered of interest group activity or corporatism; however, policy communities were found to have existed by the early 1960s.