Quantitative Science Studies · 2022 · 84 citations · 91 references
Public AffairsEconomicsHealth PolicyHealth EconomicsImpact MeasurementPolicy EvaluationBibliometric AnalysisCitation PracticesImpact EvaluationPeer ReviewResearch Impact AssessmentSource DescriptionAcademic Impact AssessmentCitation MappingField-weighted Citation ImpactImpact AssessmentPeer Review EvaluationPolicy ReviewResearch Evaluation MetricsResearch Excellence Framework
Abstract This paper presents an analysis of the Overton policy document database, describing the makeup of materials indexed and the nature in which they cite academic literature. We report on various aspects of the data, including growth, geographic spread, language representation, the range of policy source types included, and the availability of citation links in documents. Longitudinal analysis over established journal category schemes is used to reveal the scale and disciplinary focus of citations and determine the feasibility of developing field-normalized citation indicators. To corroborate the data indexed, we also examine how well self-reported funding outcomes collected by UK funders correspond to data indexed in the Overton database. Finally, to test the data in an experimental setting, we assess whether peer-review assessment of impact as measured by the UK Research Excellence Framework (REF) 2014 correlates with derived policy citation metrics. Our findings show that for some research topics, such as health, economics, social care, and the environment, Overton contains a core set of policy documents with sufficient citation linkage to academic literature to support various citation analyses that may be informative in research evaluation, impact assessment, and policy review.
91
The journal coverage of Web of Science and Scopus: a comparative analysis
Philippe Mongeon, Adèle Paul‐Hus · Scientometrics · 2015 · 4.7K citations · Full text
Bibliometrics: The Leiden Manifesto for research metrics
Diana Hicks, Paul Wouters, Ludo Waltman et al. · Nature · 2015 · 2.6K citations