Environmental trade-offs of direct air capture technologies in climate change mitigation toward 2100

Yang Qiu, Patrick Lamers, Vassilis Daioglou, Noah McQueen, Harmen Sytze de Boer, Mathijs Harmsen, Jennifer Wilcox, André Bardow, Sangwon Suh

Nature Communications · 2022 · 152 citations · 63 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Direct air capture is essential for meeting strict climate goals, but its large‑scale environmental impacts remain unexamined. The study assesses how decarbonizing electricity and improving DAC technologies are both essential to prevent shifting environmental problems. The authors conduct a prospective life cycle assessment of two DAC technologies across multiple climate mitigation scenarios. The assessment shows that while decarbonizing electricity improves sequestration efficiency, it also raises terrestrial ecotoxicity and metal depletion, which can be reduced by enhancing DAC material and energy efficiencies, and that regional impact differences underscore the need for smart siting, with DAC aiding long‑term climate goals only if sectoral decarbonization is maintained.

Abstract

Abstract Direct air capture (DAC) is critical for achieving stringent climate targets, yet the environmental implications of its large-scale deployment have not been evaluated in this context. Performing a prospective life cycle assessment for two promising technologies in a series of climate change mitigation scenarios, we find that electricity sector decarbonization and DAC technology improvements are both indispensable to avoid environmental problem-shifting. Decarbonizing the electricity sector improves the sequestration efficiency, but also increases the terrestrial ecotoxicity and metal depletion levels per tonne of CO 2 sequestered via DAC. These increases can be reduced by improvements in DAC material and energy use efficiencies. DAC exhibits regional environmental impact variations, highlighting the importance of smart siting related to energy system planning and integration. DAC deployment aids the achievement of long-term climate targets, its environmental and climate performance however depend on sectoral mitigation actions, and thus should not suggest a relaxation of sectoral decarbonization targets.

References

63