American Political Science Review · 1996 · 427 citations · 16 references
Social SciencesPolitical ScienceSociologyDemocratizationPolitical HistoryRegional StudiesComparative Regional AnalysisDemocracyIntegration Of Qualitative DataIntegration Of Quantitative DataInterregional RelationsQualitative Data CollectionQualitative Data InterpretationRegional Historical AnalysisSociopolitical Context
Political scientists are increasingly aware of integrating quantitative and qualitative data, and Robert Putnam’s *Making Democracy Work* exemplifies this trend, yet its expansion from studying administrative reform to comparing Italian democracy across regions relies on questionable historical reconstructions and qualitative inferences. This article applauds Putnam’s integration of qualitative and quantitative data but critiques his historical reconstruction of Italian democracy to fit a social‑capital model.
Political scientists are becoming more self-conscious about how they connect quantitative and qualitative data in social science and about the role of systematic country studies in comparative research. As the most striking example of both practices in recent years, Robert Putnam and his collaborators' Making Democracy Work deserves more serious criticism than it has received. While Putnam's original project aimed at a precise goal—studying how a new administrative reform is institutionalized—his ultimate project aimed at nothing less than examining how differently democracy works in different sociopolitical contexts, operationalized cross-sectionally in southern and northern Italy. The sources of these differences he found in the two regions' histories, which led him to employ the quantitative interregional data he had collected for one purpose to support a model of historical development of North and South. This historical reconstruction rests largely on qualitative data; but it also rests on a set of comparative inferences about individual values and community cohesiveness in the two regions that is of questionable historical validity and innocent of structural grounding. This article applauds Putnam's joining qualitative and quantitative data but attacks his reconstruction of Italian history to fit his model of social capital.
16
Bowling Alone: America's Declining Social Capital
Robert D. Putnam · Journal of democracy · 1995 · 14K citations
The Moral Basis of a Backward Society.
Edward C. Banfield · Economica · 1959 · 3.2K citations
Humanities, Philosophy, Ethics +10
Peasant Communism in Southern Italy
Shepard B. Clough, Sidney Tarrow · The American Historical Review · 1968 · 274 citations