Female Worlds

Molly McGarry

Journal of women's history · 2000 · 12 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

In her preface to Disorderly Conduct, Carroll Smith-Rosenberg wrote, "When all is said, it is to and for our daughters and their generation that we write. We want to tell them what we know. We wish them to understand what impelled us to fight to learn it--what it, and most especially, they, mean to us." 1 The nineteenth-century world that Smith-Rosenberg depicted in "Female World of Love and Ritual" would no doubt have been a more supportive environment for this generous generational pedagogy than was the fractious and argumentative one of women's history and feminist politics. In that nineteenth-century female world structured by intimate mother-daughter relationships, "expressions of hostility which we would today consider routine on the part of mothers and daughters seem to have been uncommon indeed." 2 By contrast, the late 1980s and early 1990s produced a new generation of less-than-dutiful daughters. With the passing of a decade and the widespread acknowledgment of the insights of "Female World of Love and Ritual," a radical and innovative thesis had been transformed into a historical given. A new cohort of historians and theorists, writing out of their own political moment, questioned what they understood as Smith-Rosenberg's insistence on the social acceptability and asexuality of passionate relationships among women. 3 But, if Smith-Rosenberg argued strongly for the first of these claims, she demurred on the second. Critics responded less to "Female World of Love and Ritual" than to scholarship it inspired--histories that seemed to misread Smith-Rosenberg's invitation to explore the same-sex passions of nineteenth-century women as prohibition against reading those passions as sexual.