George Eliot and Money: Economics, Ethics and Literature

Aeron Hunt

George Eliot - George Henry Lewes Studies · 2016 · 32 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

Dermot Coleman's George Eliot and Money: Economics, Ethics and Literature joins a still-strong current of criticism that reads Victorian literature and economic writing in tandem, finding in nineteenth-century economic anxieties a particular resonance for our own moment. Coleman's biography, referenced in the introduction to this clearly written and informative study, makes his perspective especially tantalizing: before turning back to scholarly pursuits he worked at a “venerable” (vii) financial firm and founded an investment management company. The volume makes good on the promise offered by this alternative professional expertise. Coleman casts an analyst's eye on “the Eliot-Lewes portfolio” of investments, tracking its geographical and sectoral profile, comparing it to other typical investment portfolios—for instance, one that might be devised by “a City professional” (46) as opposed to a commonplace private investor—and noting changes as John Cross came to play a greater management role. Eliot's fans will not be surprised that the novelist turns out to have anticipated today's conventional wisdom about the importance of investment diversification.If this professional financial perspective were to result in nothing more than Coleman's two appendices—a table detailing Eliot's final stock portfolio (its value, distribution, and yield), and a thorough account of Mr. Tulliver's financial difficulties, including both a legal analysis and a table of Mr. Tulliver's assets, at their fair market and distressed values, and liabilities—it would be appreciated. But Coleman's argument reaches well beyond the merely technical, reading Eliot's investment choices, for instance, as significant for what they reveal about her approach to economic questions as occasions of ethical and moral reflection. Indeed, this is Coleman's main focus across the volume's chapters, which pursue two overarching questions: “How did Eliot conceptualise economic value within her broader individual and social ethics?” and “How was the integration of economic and wider ‘good’ tested and measured within the novels?” (9). A biographical focus structures the opening chapters. The first argues that Eliot's deep engagement with political economy has been underestimated, tracing her awareness of a range of economic writing, from popular to professional, and using references to novels to uncover her positions on contemporary economic controversies. The second and third chapters examine Eliot's financial experiences—investments, familial debts, and the negotiation of payments for her novels—using them as windows into her thinking about the moral questions raised by economic decisions in a social, embedded world. In situating the author within an economic field, Coleman does not seek to place her in one intellectual camp or another; in fact, if there is a through-line to Eliot's moral-economic thinking, he suggests, it is an insistence that context and relationship trump abstract laws that claim singular keys to understanding motivation and ethics.The next two chapters place a sustained focus on novels (Felix Holt and Middlemarch, respectively), seeing them as “a form that stands outside of systems” (81), offering “‘experiments’” (89) that test different philosophical models. Felix Holt tests the principle of Utilitarian calculation that grounded much of early- and mid-century political economy; Coleman traces Eliot's responses to writers such as Adam Smith, J. S. Mill, W. S. Jevons, and writers associated with the Westminster Review to create a richly detailed background to an analysis of the novel's representation of money, arguing convincingly that it undermines calculation as a practice of moral evaluation even as it offers little in the way of a positive practical model. The Middlemarch chapter has a similar structure, incorporating an illuminating account of Eliot and Lewes's responses to debates over Kant's moral philosophy in British intellectual circles and a reading of the novel's financial themes—notably, philanthropy and debt—as indicative of a Kantian emphasis on autonomy and motivation in ethics. Chapter 6 centers on the place of “the bourgeois virtues” (103)—a term taken from the economic historian Deirdre McCloskey to signify “those traits that refer to the economic” (104)—within Eliot's conception of character. Once again embedding Eliot's fiction (The Mill on the Floss and Daniel Deronda) within a rich philosophical context that runs from Aristotle to Smith, Coleman argues that Eliot makes character, expressed in public and private actions, a central testing ground for the balance of “prudential self-interest” (104) and the valuable, outwardly oriented qualities of temperance and liberality.The final two chapters build on earlier themes in interesting ways: Chapter 7 suggests that Eliot's emphasis on social embeddedness creates a link between her writing and the emerging tradition of economic sociology that challenged the individualistic focus of political economy; by this account, Romola's representation of a distant and historically distinct social world allows Eliot to offer a version of what has come to be called the sociological imagination as an essential interpretive tool for understanding economic actions and beliefs. The last chapter considers an intellectual linkage between Eliot and theorists of the “new liberalism,” a late-century group of thinkers who reconsidered “old” liberalism's focus on economic self-interest to advocate a more active, even statist promotion of the common good—including considerations of taxation, welfare, education, and so forth. Coleman's fascinating, nuanced argument in this chapter bears out the risks of its admittedly “speculative” (12) line of inquiry, casting a new light on the question of Eliot's politics.Even as it ventures to speculate on some fronts, George Eliot and Money remains grounded in the project of intellectual history. This is a formidable strength, but one that occasionally calls for a little air to be let into the tightly focused argument—to open up the question of whether Eliot's approach to money questions was unique or uniquely significant among novelists, for instance; or to expand the theoretical discussion of the difference it makes to reconfigure an intellectual history by including fictions. But this is an extremely satisfying work, not least in Coleman's insistent reminder, through Eliot, that the theory and the lived experience of Victorian economics were inevitably both moral and social.AERON HUNT is Assistant Professor of English at Boston College. She is the author of Personal Business: Character and Commerce in Victorian Literature and Culture. Her current research focuses on Victorian representations of veterans.