Perspectives in biology and medicine · 1959 · 73 citations · 0 references
Life SciencesBiologyEvolutionary BiologyDevelopmental PhysiologyEvolutionary TheoryMolecular EvolutionBehavioral AdaptationChromosome BiologyEvolution
PERSPECTIVES IN BIOLOGY AND MEDICINE Volume II · Number 4 · Summer 1959 EVOLUTIONARY ADAPTATION C. H. WADDINGTON, ScD., F.R.S.* The origin ofadaptation ... is the primary problem ofevolutionary biology.—George Gaylord Simpson, in Behavior and Evolution (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1958). The assemblage of "life-sciences" which are usually classed, together as "biology" form a group at least as complex and. diversified as the whole group ofthe physical sciences. Within this enormous range one can perhaps discern three main foci around which the individual sciences tend to cluster. One of these is analytical biology—the attempt to determine the ultimate constituent units upon which the character of living things depends . Analytical biology studies development and heredity through the analysis ofgenes and subgenic units and so to the macrochemical entities such as the DNA, RNA, and protein of the chromosomes. The whole group of such studies plays the same role in the biological field as does atomic physics in the physical sciences. Another major focus ofinterest is what may be called "physiological biology"—that is, the study of the mechanisms by which organisms carry on their existence. This corresponds perhaps to chemistry and engineering in the physical role. Finally, there is what may be called "synthetic biology," which is concerned to provide an intellectually coherent picture of the whole realm of living matter. In the structure ofbiology this fulfils the same role as cosmology does in the physical sciences; andjust as in the physical realm we find cosmology and atomic physics have very close connections with each other, so in biology the analytical and synthetic approaches to the world ofthe living find themselves employing very similar concepts. * Institute of Animal Genetics, Edinburgh 9, Scotland. This essay is the body oí a paper that the author will present at the Darwin Centennial Celebration to be held at the University of Chicago, November 18-24, IQ59· 379 In the hundred years since Darwin wrote, it has become universally accepted that the only synthetic biological theory which needs serious consideration is that ofevolution. In an appraisal ofevolutionary biology as it stands now in this centenary year, it is perhaps well to begin by reminding ourselves of the fundamental reasons for mankind's interest in this subject. During the century ofintensive work which has been devoted to its study, so many detailed problems have emerged which have a great fascination oftheir own that one is sometimes inclined to be carried away by enthusiasm for these puzzles, which, however, are really attractive only to those who have already taken their first steps toward this direction of study. The enormous impact ofDarwin's theories on the whole intellectual life of his own day—and, indeed, on that of all later generations— arose not from details but from the relevance of the broad outline of his thinking to one ofthe major problems with which mankind is faced. That problem is presented by the appearance of design in the organic world. Animals and plants in their innumerable variety present, ofcourse, many odd, striking, and even beautiful features, which can raise feelings of surprise and delight in the observer. But over and above this, a very large number ofthem give the appearance ofbeing astonishingly well tailored to fit precisely into the requirements which will be made ofthem by their mode of existence. Fish are admirably designed for swimming, birds for flying, horses for running, snakes for creeping, and so on, and the correspondence between what an organism will do and the way it is formed to carry out such tasks often extends into extraordinary detail. It is clear from the oldest literature that man has always been impressed by this correspondence. The simplest explanation—the one almost universally adopted in prescientific times—is to suppose that this appearance reflects the activités ofan intelligent Being who has designed each type of animal and plant in a way suitable for carrying out the functions assigned to it. It is the challenge presented to this explanation that constitutes the major interest ofthe theory ofevolution, and a really convincing alternative account of the origin of biological adaptation is the major demand which must be made of it. The essential feature of an...