High throughput screening of bisphenols and their mixtures under conditions of low-intensity adipogenesis of human mesenchymal stem cells (hMSCs)

Abstract

In vitro models of adipogenesis are phenotypic assays that most closely mimic the increase of adipose tissue in obesity. Current models, however, often lack throughput and sensitivity and even report conflicting data regarding adipogenic potencies of many chemicals. Here, we describe a ten-day long adipogenesis model using high content analysis readouts for adipocyte number, size, and lipid content on primary human mesenchymal stem cells (MSC) sensitive enough to compare bisphenol A derivatives quantitatively in a robust and high throughput manner. The number of adipocytes was the most sensitive endpoint capable of detecting changes of 20% and was used to develop a benchmark concentration model (BMC) to quantitatively compare eight bisphenols (tested at 0.1-100 μM). The model was applied to evaluate mixtures of bisphenols obtaining the first experimental evidence of their additive effect on human MSC adipogenesis. Using the relative potency factors (RPFs), we show how a mixture of bisphenols at their sub-active concentrations induces a significant adipogenic effect due to its additive nature. The final active concentrations of bisphenols in tested mixtures reached below 1 μM, which is within the concentration range observed in humans. These results point to the need to consider the toxicity of chemical mixtures.