Diseases of the Colon & Rectum · 2021 · 11 citations · 33 references
MedicineRadiologySurgeryDiagnostic ImagingDiagnostic RadiologyGastroenterologyGastrointestinal ImagingPelvic AssessmentPelvic Floor DisordersPelvic Floor HealthPelvic ImagingColorectal Surgery EducationPelvic DiagnosisPelvic Imaging AssessmentPelvic Magnetic Resonance Imaging
The Pelvic Floor Disorders Consortium (PFDC) is a multidisciplinary organization of colorectal surgeons, urogynecologists, urologists, gynecologists, gastroenterologists, radiologists, physiotherapists, and other advanced care practitioners. Specialists from these fields are all dedicated to the diagnosis and management of patients with pelvic floor conditions, but they approach, evaluate, and treat such patients with their own unique perspectives given the differences in their respective training. The PFDC was formed to bridge gaps and enable collaboration between these specialties. The goal of the PFDC is to develop and evaluate educational programs, create clinical guidelines and algorithms, and promote high quality of care in this unique patient population. The recommendations included in this document represent the work of the PFDC Working Group on Magnetic Resonance Imaging of Pelvic Floor Disorders (members listed alphabetically in Table 1). The objective was to generate inclusive, rather than prescriptive, guidance for all practitioners, irrespective of discipline, involved in the evaluation and treatment of patients with pelvic floor disorders. TABLE 1. - Members of the working group Name and degree Affiliation City, state, country Jennifer Ayscue, M.D. Division of Colorectal Surgery, MedStar Washington Hospital Center North Washington, DC, USA Pedro Basilio, M.D. Department of Colorectal Surgery, Clinica de Saúde Intestinal Rio de Janeiro, Brazil Victoria Chernyak, M.D. Department of Radiology, Albert Einstein College of Medicine, Montefiore Medical Center The Bronx, NY, USA Rania Farouk El Sayed, M.D. Cairo University Pelvic Floor Centre of Excellency and Research Lab, Department of Radiology, Faculty of Medicine, Cairo University Hospitals. Cairo, Egypt Brooke Gurland, M.D. Division of Colorectal Surgery. Stanford University Palo Alto, CA, USA Cynthia Hall, M.D. Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology UMass Memorial Medical Center Worcester, MA, USA Karin Herrmann, M.D. Department of Radiology, University Hospitals of Cleveland Cleveland, OH, USA Kedar Jambhekar, M.D. Department of Radiology, University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences, Little Rock, AR, USA Andreas M. Kaiser, M.D. Division of Colorectal Surgery, City of Hope National Cancer Center Duarte, CA, USA Amita Kamath, M.D. Department of Radiology, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai New York, NY, USA Gaurav Khatri, M.D. Department of Radiology, University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center Dallas, TX, USA Erin Kocjancic, M.D. Department of Urology College of Medicine University of Illinois Chicago, IL, USA Khashayar Rafatzand, M.D. Department of Radiology, UMass Memorial Medical Center Worcester, MA, USA Luz Maria Rodriguez, M.D. Division of Colorectal Surgery National Cancer Institute Rockville, MD, USA Kavita Mishra, M.D. Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Stanford University Palo Alto, CA, USA Leila Neshatian, M.D. Division of Gastroenterology, Stanford University Palo Alto, CA, USA Erin O’Neill, M.D. Department of Radiology, MedStar Washington Hospital Center North Washington, DC, USA Albert Parlade, M.D. Department of Radiology, Cleveland Clinic Weston, FL, USA Raj Mohan Paspulati, M.D. Department of Radiology, University Hospitals Cleveland Medical Center Cleveland, OH USA Roopa Ram, M.D. Department of Radiology, University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences Little Rock, AR, USA Vipul Sheth, M.D. Department of Radiology, Stanford University Palo Alto, CA, USA Ari Steiner, M.D. Department of Radiology, Mount Sinai South Nassau Hospital Oceanside, NY, USA Raveen Syan, M.D. Department of Urology, University of Miami Miller School of Medicine Miami, FL, USA Amber Traugott, M.D. Division of Colorectal Surgery, The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center Columbus, OH, USA STATEMENT OF THE PROBLEM Magnetic resonance defecography (MRD) has emerged and continues to evolve as a powerful tool for dynamic evaluation of pelvic floor function. Magnetic resonance defecography provides multicompartment visualization and is able to evaluate the complex and dynamic interplay of the 3 pelvic floor compartments.1 In addition to providing global assessment of pelvic floor function, MRD can provide exquisite assessment of the pelvic floor anatomy because of its high-contrast resolution. Known limitations of MRD include the varied techniques used in performing this examination as well as the differences in nomenclature and reporting of MRD findings across different institutions and subspecialties. Furthermore, various experts involved in the care of patients with pelvic floor dysfunction sometimes use different definitions for the same condition and various thresholds for grading severity, consequently hindering consistent and effective communication between clinicians in the same institution and across institutions. To help standardize MRD technique, expert radiologists from the Pelvic Floor Dysfunction Disease Focused Panel of the Society of Abdominal Radiology (SAR) have recently published recommendations for MRD protocol and technique.2 However, these recently published recommendations from the SAR as well as other previous publications on dynamic MRD of the pelvic floor have lacked substantial multidisciplinary input from clinicians in other specialties.3,4 Consequently, there is a lack of shared understanding and “cross-talk” between various specialties involved in the care of patients with pelvic floor dysfunction, resulting in high variability in how different physicians and specialties interpret and utilize findings seen on MRD. This is of particular concern in this field of pelvic floor disorders, where patients often have recurrent or multifactorial symptomatology and seek care from multiple different specialists serially. Furthermore, multiple health care providers may be managing different aspects of pelvic floor dysfunction in the same patient in parallel. This can frequently create misunderstandings and confusion for both health care providers and patients. Thus, this effort was undertaken with the explicit goal of inviting and including representatives from all relevant clinical specialties for whom MRD holds clinical significance. The goal of this effort was to create a universal set of recommendations and language for MRD technique, interpretation, and reporting that can be utilized and carry the same significance across disciplines. Notably, pelvic floor disorders can manifest in both male and female patients. These recommendations do not make a distinction based on patient sex; however, certain recommendations may only be applicable to female pelvic floor anatomy, and normal criteria for pelvic floor imaging in male patients are less well established. METHODOLOGY This document was created at the initiative of the Pelvic Floor Disorders Consortium (PFDC) Working Group on MRI. The PFDC is composed of a volunteer cohort of clinicians with demonstrated expertise in the care and treatment of pelvic floor conditions. The working group was created by enlisting Pelvic Floor Consortium volunteers. Invitation criteria included leadership in the field of pelvic floor disorders with academic scholarship and a history of interdisciplinary collaboration. Members of the working group participated in preliminary group phone calls and researched assigned topics (Table 1). A radiologist was paired with a clinical specialist for each of the working group topics. An organized search of MEDLINE, PubMed, EMBASE, and the Cochrane Database of Collected Reviews was performed on July 1, 2018, and repeated on September 1, 2018. Retrieved publications were limited to the English language but no limits on year of publication were applied. The search terms included: “Dynamic MRI,” “Dynamic pelvic floor MR,” “MR defecography,” “Pelvic floor MR,” “Positioning for MR defecography,” “levator descent,” “pelvic organ prolapse,” “rectocele,” “rectal emptying,” “cystocele,” “rectal intussusception,” “Cul-de-sac hernias pelvic floor,” “uterine prolapse,” “Vaginal prolapse,” “urethral hypermobility,” “pubococcygeal line,” “pelvic floor dyssynergia,” and “anorectal angle.” Each working group pair identified the updated literature on the assigned relevant topic or point of controversy regarding MRD technique and/or reporting and performed a careful review of the pertinent literature using a standardized literature review format. A collective summary document of the researched topics was generated and used as a reference to steer discussion at the PFDC meeting. The working group presented their preliminary research to the consortium at large for further discussion. Pelvic Floor Consortium Expert Meeting The Pelvic Floor Consortium Expert Meeting convened on June 2, 2019, in Cleveland, Ohio. It was hosted and funded by the American Society of Colon and Rectal Surgeons (ASCRS) and included 126 in-person (or online) volunteer participants from North America, Europe, and Asia. These experts belonged to several subspecialties (colorectal surgery, gastroenterology, urogynecology, urology, physiotherapy, and radiology), and professional societies involved in the diagnosing and treating of pelvic floor disorders. The event was also audited by formal representatives from the ASCRS, the SAR, the International Continence Society, the American Urogynecologic Society, the International Urogynecology Association, and the Society Gynecologic Surgeons who then reported back to their leadership on the event. The participants at the expert consensus meeting analyzed all the proposed radiological definitions measuring each of the conditions reviewed in this statement, ultimately recommending a synoptic reporting template that included the recommended steps for a thorough and clinically relevant examination, as well as the clinically relevant radiological definitions for common evacuatory pelvic floor disorders seen on defecography. They labeled this final template as the “Magnetic Resonance Imaging Defecography Interpretation Template for the Initial Measurement of Patient Reported Pelvic Floor Complaints” or “MRI-IMPACT” (Table 2). For a recommendation to be included in the MRI-IMPACT template, an expert consensus was required. Consensus was defined as at least 70% agreement or more from the voting participants. When consensus was not reached, the workgroups performed additional research and literature reviews to clarify any questions raised the meeting. A meeting was to final voting on the recommendations and definitions listed in the MRI-IMPACT the of the expert consensus in TABLE - MRI-IMPACT template defecography with of was the of the was performed were with patient in careful patient used for findings including pertinent of and of the was by the of the to the are consistent patients to are consistent and the the findings are consistent with and at with and of the of to of to of to pelvic of to Rectal The the same The is at and at the point of to findings as 1. and not the document was the proposed recommendations were presented for review by the Pelvic Floor Disorders This is to develop clinical recommendations on colorectal pelvic floor disorders based on The the document and to the for final for reviews and were also given by the American Urogynecologic Society the SAR of and SAR Disease Focused Panel on Pelvic Floor the International Continence Society of the International Urogynecology of and the of the Society Gynecologic 1. MRD can be performed in the or and the be in the to provide for the imaging findings of Magnetic resonance defecography can be performed in or The or is more and the of to in the can be or for who on or various such as to their However, institutions lack to and the have for MRD in the MRD to have A to MRD in the same patient demonstrated of the and but no in of the A by demonstrated that MRD and were not different in terms of of and However, that MRD and to defecography. a more and on MRD than on For and defecography to MRD in and demonstrated that MRD was less than defecography for diagnosing and but was in for demonstrated no differences between defecography and MRD for the from different consortium that is to MRD in the MRD is not consortium experts that is that this imaging be performed patient on the of the The of this is to promote patient of the the of patient effort is further MRD quality is on patient and be on the and the steps of the MRD examination to their with the examination of Patient is to a and MRD The consortium experts that patients the examination regarding to and the of the in a more are to then of on with effort to physicians can this of patient by the examination and its for patient management to the patients in or on the phone or at the the physicians the of patient effort the to the educational or were recommended to patients the examination their at the of to the examination can help patient and this unique The patients be given an to any questions or on at the Furthermore, the consortium experts that is for radiologists or to the patients the examination they can resulting in the quality terms such as and be in language patients are in the and the is The may be as pelvic floor as to the of or the may be as on the pelvic floor any and may be as with of The patient be to each for the of as by the performing the is to any confusion on the of the patient 1. Rectal and are for an MRD examination in both female and male patients of on the in the literature and the of the the consortium recommended that MRD be performed with using and with of Rectal and are of an MRD examination and from dynamic pelvic floor performed with the have and/or more on MRD with and on to Rectal is an of the technique to various institutions have with different for use or in the by using with a This is to and is well by in the may assessment of in other may not the to as a more of To there is no in the literature the use of of for MRD. The of used also between from to there is a of literature the of in the a no in the of effort with to and use of the to patient and of in other to the consortium experts not the of to be to use an that the may be to with or of and the the patient not or an to The of used be in the A with a history of and of at and the and at or the at in in the the and there is a the is than at but the and there is of the in there is of the the and of the the the and there is of the the are also and and Magnetic resonance defecography not use of for imaging of of institutions use on MRD in female patients to in of and have reported using from to but there is no in the literature to use of MRD. its high and visualization of in the such as the and and and the for use of and the on patient and Furthermore, the is not the examination, of the or in other Thus, there was consensus the experts the use of for A with a with the to and at of the and a in A is from the to the of the at in is in using a from this to the of the in in and in are These findings were not on the is also of the on the in A with a history of and and of the at The are well a is the and of the on the in from the same patient a large in more and in and of 1. on MRD are on patient effort be reported as or to provide clinical of Furthermore, patients be to is or at least 3 the examination of the degree of be and reported as a of in The and of effort be of It is to based on their clinical and in the experts that MRD be rather than only a They that the lack of a may the of and may in an of pelvic floor on Thus, experts recommended not a of but rather to a where patients are to or can be to on experts recommended a of 3 in in the to the In such the often a degree of or that may have on and of the set of the degree of effort or degree of dysfunction be used for is not these who do not the examination may be to to in a the or by to the This be by an additional set of MR to any that may have by a or only on the These be labeled for A with pelvic organ and a limited clinical in less and to effort in large in with on the the of from the the of the the from also on the of the effort that can be by patient the examination and by for on the at The of of the with of may The of in this may the the degree of be by reporting the of as a of the in or all was The experts also that the of be reported because may have clinical in the evaluation and treatment of dysfunction conditions of a more in the to from a or the of This may between various of such as pelvic floor to a or recommendation The be the used as the point of reference to the of in all of the pelvic floor of the be defined as a the of the to the not the of is an that patients with pelvic organ or to the in all 3 to the of the of experts to treat the Thus, the consortium experts that the of in and be and to help clinicians the and have used as reference can the of the pelvic The is the used reference and has agreement reported radiologists than with other The is also recommended for assessment of by the Society of Radiology and the Society of and Abdominal Radiology working group on pelvic floor The is on from the point of the to the The of various pelvic and can then be in using to the These are at and and grading of to published A patient with the the from the of the to the of pelvic the can be to the the of the to the the use of other experts proposed the as because is not by pelvic and may be more The has also with clinical examination for and providing further as to its clinical The the of the was as a reference but not recommended because of reported and have in using the as a reference in a of than the this was to be of such as or be by measuring their the of in the point of the in to the of of or pelvic of grading of as may not be clinically relevant of such as the the or can be in the between the and the These hernias to be clinically relevant they the on and the the or This can of their or the Imaging may help the from as a of on examination, in may be or with on at the experts that the radiological of hernias on MRD include not only of their the but also of the to the It is not is for but careful of these can help a understanding of these and help also that in of patient given the lack of consensus on how these findings be and the that their is based on clinical the MRD not these as or In of or the a as to these to the It is also to that or effort on MRD may for of because these are often seen or with an of other dysfunction seen on the examination, is to the of any dysfunction of the can be seen with that treatment with for the be by a to the and measuring the of the of the in to the at and of In addition to pelvic organ patients may with is to the of recurrent and patient with their The or of can provide clinical to the of pelvic organ and be such as the and the can be used to and The the of the pelvic floor and is from the of the to the The is a from the to the of the at the and can be used as in of given the lack of other The experts that these be used to and of A with and at A the The is from the of the to the and the is from the to the of the and the an the and with the is also an be in by measuring the of the from its at to the include regarding and in the degree of of the any of grading of as or may not be clinically relevant and be of is often to is defined as or of the the may and of the and manifest as a and/or However, both and hernias can in on Furthermore, sometimes on clinical examination may not manifest on imaging with MRD. the between examination and imaging for the of regarding of of on imaging and not on examination (or are often multifactorial based on the and and discussion of is the of these the consortium experts that be seen on MRD and be in A from the the normal of the at A from this to the of the be the of the Furthermore, any of the be to other radiologists using language that or grading such as because the imaging may not with patient be on the with effort or they It was that a on MRD not with the of on because of differences in between the of used for and MRI. When a not a further be as to the patient can with or Furthermore, in patients who have a of the or of the with a the of the in to the of the of the pelvic floor can provide further the treatment to these patients. be as or of Rectal in male or female patients to the or of the the more or the or of is but the radiological may with conditions such as pelvic floor and that may patients to have In this careful and grading of the is clinically The literature on the and for for this is there to be consensus that the patients who at a and of may from The of in the patient with of the pelvic floor and/or a concern of is to and the of care are more the clinical the consortium experts of to use for grading reporting or the the that a consistent of as or provide clinical and be used as the reporting Notably, the “rectal is used in for of in both and Thus, the of the on imaging in terms of may help The of using the more to the of the the was but ultimately experts its in the reporting template for the consensus not These additional as to the is or or can be clinicians that these additional radiological may have on When further also be as to its on and as to its in to the of the and to the of in different patients of the and the more for a consistent with A large is seen in of the and of the the consistent with in a patient a with and is also a the the in the from the to and the be on MRD of dysfunction including pelvic floor defined as of the is a of in male or female The of is because pelvic floor and is the only treatment Furthermore, or in the of other can surgery, and to there is no for the diagnosis of dysfunction and the often a of clinical including and/or dynamic to the other has the of providing both and and be an in the evaluation of patients with of Magnetic resonance defecography is at the and to the The is on MRD at the and as the between a the and the of the reported that in the is at to at the and to the of the may across a the and the to its at The imaging of a patient with however, is of the and Thus, is to not only the but also the of of the from on MRD. male and female patients have a than at The consortium that a of both the degree of as well as the be in clinical A with recurrent and normal in of of the to in of the in to on in A with and pelvic organ normal in of and of the in to the of in Consensus was by the PFDC on clinically relevant for and reporting defecography. A synoptic template was based on these consensus guidelines (Table 2). The technique and template can be with additional radiological and based on patient health care and but the and steps be as the performing and MRD in patients with disorders of the pelvic
33
Satish S.C. Rao, Adil E. Bharucha, Giuseppe Chiarioni et al. · Gastroenterology · 2016 · 512 citations
Pelvic floor descent in women: dynamic evaluation with fast MR imaging and cinematic display.
Andrew Yang, Jacek L. Mostwin, N. Rosenshein et al. · Radiology · 1991 · 357 citations
Medicine, Gynecology, Radiology +16
Frederick M. Kelvin, Dean D. T. Maglinte, Douglass S. Hale et al. · American Journal of Roentgenology · 2000 · 285 citations
Medicine, Gynecology, Radiology +17