Free Global DEMs and Flood Modelling—A Comparison Analysis for the January 2015 Flooding Event in Mocuba City (Mozambique)

Julio Garrote

Water · 2022 · 49 citations · 71 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Flood hazard analysis in developing countries is hampered by limited flow data and low‑quality digital elevation models. The study compared eight free global DEMs—ALOS Palsar, Aster GDEM, Bare Earth, SRTM, Merit, TanDEM‑X, NASA, and Copernicus—by reconstructing the January 2015 flood in Mocuba using gauge‑derived peak flows and evaluating depth predictions at control points through visual and statistical analysis. Copernicus DEM produced markedly better visual and statistical flood depth estimates than the other DEMs, and its hazard analysis matched historical impact data, underscoring its value for flood risk assessment in developing countries and the role of citizen‑science field data.

Abstract

Flood hazard and risk analysis in developing countries is a difficult task due to the absence or scarce availability of flow data and digital elevation models (DEMs) with the necessary quality. Up to eight DEMs (ALOS Palsar, Aster GDEM, Bare Earth DEM, SRTM DEM, Merit DEM, TanDEM-X DEM, NASA DEM, and Copernicus DEM) of different data acquisition, spatial resolution, and data processing were used to reconstruct the January 2015 flood event. The systematic flow rate record from the Mocuba city gauge station as well as international aid organisms and field data were used to define both the return period peak flows in years for different flood frequencies (Tyear) and the January 2015 flooding event peak flow. Both visual and statistical analysis of flow depth values at control point locations give us a measure of the different hydraulic modelling performance. The results related to the Copernicus DEM, both in visual and statistical approach, show a clear improvement over the results of the other free global DEMs. Under the assumption that Copernicus DEM provides the best results, a flood hazard analysis was carried out, its results being in agreement with previous data of the effects of the January 2015 flooding event in the Mocuba District. All these results highlight the step forward that Copernicus DEM represents for flood hazard analysis in developing countries, along with the use of so-called “citizen science” in the form of flooding evidence field data acquisition.

References

71