The Morphogenesis of Subchapter C: An Essay in Statutory Evolution and Reform

Robert C. Clark

The Yale Law Journal · 1977 · 12 citations · 0 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

By anyone's reckoning, the law concerning the federal income taxation of corporations and security holders-essentially, subchapter C of the Internal Revenue Code, 1 together with its accompanying regulations 2 and the accumulated body of revenue rulings and case law 3 -is complex.Quite surprisingly for a corpus of rules that is an artificial construct of highly self-conscious human intellects, rather than an attempt to rationalize preexisting social relations, the law exhibits an intricacy approaching that of living systems.The analogy suggests a question.Did the corporate tax law, like a mature organism, have its major traits determined by a set of genes fixed in its infancy, or did it grow in a passive, mechanistic way, its important parts constantly shaped and reshaped in response to the shifting pressures of a changin g environment?The inquiry as to whether corporate tax law be animal or machine may best be advanced by adopting the perspective of a cultural anthropologist.Though "culture" is a term often used to denote a society's total system of symbols, 4 "a" culture may usefully be defined