Design and Debris: A Chaotics of Postmodern American Fiction (review)

Guy Rotella

Studies in American fiction · 2002 · 18 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

Studies in American Fiction253 herently indifferent to predetermined political agendas, Bramen has a nice knack for turning common-place assumptions on their heads, for making arguments that look, on their faces, counterintuitive, but upon closer inspection reveal the tensions in the taken-for-granted pieties about terms of inclusion and exclusion. Key terms, she shows us, have served competing political and social agendas, and have proven surprisingly supple when put to unexpected uses by various social actors. Second, The Uses ofVariety proceeds in a clear, straight-forward style. Its prose is both even-handed and level-headed, traits that recommend it to a wide readership. Although I have singled out for praise some of the more rébarbative intellectual moves of her book, Bramen is no dogmatist, and her prose reflects this. Her arguments and her tone are lucid, uncluttered by recourse to abstract formulations—indeed, suspicion toward truisms and pat summings-up inform the trajectory of the book as a whole. Situated at the juncture of a number of important conversations in American studies, this is an important and timely book. Because Bramen shows us how conversations about racial and ethnic difference were shaped, her book should be a key text for critics wishing to shape a similar conversation now, and because it is carefully researched and thoughtfully argued, it will certainly remain a key text in the field. University of Illinois at Urbana-ChampaignStephanie Foote Conte, Joseph M. Design andDebris: A Chaotics ofPostmodernAmerican Fiction. Tuscaloosa: The Univ. of Alabama Press, 2002. 272 pp. Cloth: $59.95; paper: $24.95. In Unending Design (1991), Joseph Conte offered a typology of postmodern poetry, arranging its practices under doubly divided rubrics: finite or infinite serial forms and predetermined or generative procedural ones. As a self-styled "chaotics," Design and Debris is less schematic. Nonetheless (and therefore), it does similar work for recent American fiction, parsing its prescient, indebted, or coincident versions of ideas of disorderly order which emerged in several fields during the final third of the twentieth century . In those years, the "new sciences" of cybernetics, fractal geometry, chaos theory, and nonlinear dynamics joined critical theory and other contemporary disciplines in rejecting the traditional Western view of chaos and order as starkly opposed conditions (unknown or known, ugly or beautiful, evil or good). They viewed them instead as interdependent aspects of openended and ongoing systems, systems that vibrate endlessly between unity and multiplicity as patterns appear in what had seemed random and disorder arises in what had seemed shaped. This interpretation is anti-dualist and relational but not quite monistic. It interrogates standard scientific versions of 254Reviews reality as well as conventional literary, social, and political arrangements. It affirms turbulence for its dual capacity to disrupt rigid orders (which only force can sustain) and to provide the conditions from which new, more flexible orders can appear. Meanwhile, Design and Debris is commodious but not comprehensive. Most of the writers discussed are chronologically "postmodern," but here "postmodern" defines specific thematic and formal inclinations within the broader period: preferences for non-centrist, non-hierarchical dispersals ofinformation and authority, for instance, or predilictions for structures whose orders "self-organize" from instability or whose apparent irregularities prove symmetrical across divergent scales. An introductory chapter surveys disorderly order in several fields, connecting , among other things, Wiener's feedback loops, the World Wide Web, Lyotard' s science of instabilities, Deleuze and Guattari' s rhizomes, nomads, and smooth space, Mandelbrot's fractals, and Prigogine' s work on the spontaneous self-organizing negetropic potential in non-equilibrium thermodynamic systems. Related by their move toward chaotics, those ideas and practices typically stress order either as immanent within apparent chaos (as in the Mandelbrot set) or as emerging from turbulence (as in Prigogine' s investigations). While avoiding what Marianne Moore called "neatness of finish," Conte applies those emphases to postmodern novelists, distinguishing proceduralists like Robert Coover and Harry Matthews, who use predetermined constraints to generate "the content, trajectory, and orderliness" of their work from disrupters like Kathy Acker and William Burroughs, who scrupulously avoid determining structures but propose that out ofdisorderliness "a capacity for self-organization may emerge." This is a sturdily pliant scheme, appended to a genial and learned...