Journal of international affairs · 2014 · 25 citations · 0 references
Social SciencesConflict StudiesPolitical ScienceAfrican StudiesArmed ConflictPolitical ViolenceAfrican PoliticsCivil WarConflict In AfricaHumanitarian Impact Of WarPeace NegotiationPeace ProcessesCivil War DynamicsCivil War LegaciesCivil War Peace AgreementsIdeological ViolencePeace PracticePeacebuilding In Fragile StatesPolitical NegotiationSouth Sudan History
When elephants fight, it's grass that suffers. (1) There are several similar versions of this Kenyan proverb, both in Swahili and other African languages, that all describe same thing: the feeling of powerlessness in midst of larger forces. (2) Few sayings so aptly describe devastating impact that power wrangling, and consequent violence, is currently having on South Sudan's vulnerable and defenseless population. Since mid-December 2013, when civil war broke out in South Sudan between President Salva Kiir's government forces and opposition rebels, led by former Vice President Riek Machar, repeated attempts to reach a negotiated peace settlement have failed. The Intergovernmental Authority on Development (IGAD), East Africa's eight-country trade bloc, has been facilitating peace talks, which have been held in Ethiopia--initially in Addis Ababa and then in Bahir Dar. While peace remains elusive and fighting continues, urgent humanitarian situation in South Sudan is deteriorating rapidly. The failure to end ongoing conflict can be attributed to both numerous and complex causes of violence, as well as to an apparent lack of political will from either side to end fighting. This article will first examine various factors that have contributed to unfortunate violence that we see in South Sudan today, and will then explore possible ways forward for country. A reflection on why world's youngest nation descended into civil war less than three years after its establishment reveals, among other things, enduring importance of key elements of good governance: effective separation and devolution of powers, appropriate government and electoral systems, establishment of strong institutions, and good fiscal management. So, too, public participation and ensuring that all voices are heard and represented plays an invaluable role. WHAT CAUSED THE CIVIL WAR IN SOUTH SUDAN? On 15 December 2013, President Kiir, an ethnic Dinka, accused his former Vice President Riek Machar, an ethnic Nuer, of attempting to overthrow him in a coup. It remains unclear whether such a coup attempt actually took place; nevertheless, violence quickly broke out in Juba, nation's capital. Although often touted as an ethnic war, role of ethnicity in actually triggering conflict is uncertain. Of eleven politicians arrested by government in connection with alleged coup, six were Dinkas, two were Nuers, and other three were from different ethnic groups, thus seemingly negating possible ethnic motivations. (3) Regardless of initial role of ethnicity in conflict, as fighting continued and spread beyond Juba, violence became increasingly ethnic, largely pitting Dinkas against Nuers. Despite these apparent ethnic divisions, no insurmountable hostility seems to exist between South Sudan's ethnic groups; rather, these divisions are result of patronage systems that have tended to develop along ethnic lines. Ethnic patronage is understandable, given natural comfort, ease, and familiarity in working with those with whom one shares common bonds and language. Still, patronage and access to resources that patronage brings are undoubtedly significant underlying causes of violence. Accordingly, one could say that [t]he fault lies not in DNA of South Sudanese tribes. It lies with political leaders who use ethnic patronage to build their power bases; or who incite their ethnic kin to carve out a geographic or political niche. (4) While natural, inclination to work only with one's own ethnic and linguistic group must be consciously overcome, particularly in diverse populations, such as that of South Sudan. A number of other factors appear to have contributed to outbreak of violence, which ended two years of relative peace that South Sudan had enjoyed since establishment of country in 2011. …