1997 · 15 citations · 0 references
EngineeringCivil EngineeringBridge EngineeringEarthquake EngineeringStructural EngineeringBridge DesignBridge FoundationsBridge Structural AnalysisEarthquake Response Of StructuresStructural DesignStructural Response AnalysisCritical Acceleration ThresholdsDisplacement-based DesignSeismic CapacitySeismic Loss EstimationSeismic Performance Of BridgesSeismic Vulnerability AssessmentSoil - Foundation InteractionSoil-foundation Interaction
Depending on their seismic resistance, existing bridge abutments may be vulnerable to earthquakes. Seismic resistance may be quantified in terms of a threshold acceleration level beyond which permanent deformation will occur. During a seismic event, whenever the ground acceleration exceeds the threshold, permanent deformation accumulates. The current displacement-based design procedure considers only the possibility of a sliding mode of failure between the abutment and foundation soil. The procedure allows one to estimate the amount of permanent horizontal displacement given relevant earthquake parameters, and the seismic resistance of the bridge abutment. However, results from recent studies demonstrate the possibility of seismic loss of bearing capacity, and subsequent rotation, or mixed sliding/rotation modes of failure. Herein, a revised analytic method is described for determining the most critical threshold acceleration. The method considers the possibility of sliding, bearing capacity, or mixed modes of failure. Details of the load transfer between the bridge abutment and the bridge deck are also incorporated. To verify the accuracy of the newly developed analytic method, a series of shaking table tests was conducted on model bridge abutments. The tests were unique in the sense that failure was not constrained to one particular mode. Models could fail by sliding, excessive tilting or a mixed mode depending on the geometry of the wall, connection details between the bridge abutment and the bridge deck, and properties of the backfill and foundation soil. The results from these tests verify the analytic procedure for predicting critical threshold acceleration based on simple theory. Computation of predicted displacements and rotation are reasonable. Thus it is now possible, with this analytic tool, to evaluate the seismic vulnerability of existing abutments. This is demonstrated for a representative sample of 40 bridges with free-standing abutments from New York State. It appears that significant numbers are at risk from an earthquake with peak accelerations above 0.15g. The results indicate that extending this easy screening procedure to other areas in the East and Midwest in moderate earthquake zones would be worthwhile. The theory also relates directly to design recommendations to increase the seismic capacity of both existing bridge abutments and new designs. Not only can the critical threshold acceleration be made higher with passive restraint footing keys, piles or tiebacks but girder seats, knock-off walls and transverse restraint can be designed to reduce damage in extreme events.