More Than Enjoying the Sunset: Conceptualization and Measurement of Religiosity for Adolescents and Emerging Adults and Its Implications for Developmental Inquiry

Laura DeHaan, Julie E. Yonker, Carolyn Affholter

˜The œJournal of psychology and Christianity · 2011 · 25 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

Although religious belief is common among most American adolescents and emerging adults (individuals between 18 and 29), studies examining the effects of religious beliefs on this population are limited. Studies rarely pose the question whether spirituality and religiosity (S/R) influence normative development, or whether development influences S/R. Studies of religious belief are also characterized by limitations in conceptualization, methodology and operational definition. To further understand how S/R has been studied in these developmental periods, we analyzed all identified empirical studies from 1990 to 2010 that focused on adolescents and emerging adults, in which some aspect of religion, spirituality and/or faith was an identified variable. Studies were examined in terms of conceptual and operational definition, and methodological strategy. Our analyses indicated a wide variety of strategies on how religiosity was conceptualized and measured, as well as a low level of congruity conceptualization of S/R and how these concepts were actually measured. Little research examined important developmental transitions, and few studies were longitudinal. Suggestions for improving research on adolescents and emerging adults are discussed within a developmental framework. Although most American adolescents and emerging adults (individuals between 18 and 29) believe in God (Smith & Snell, 2009), the relationships between religious faith to adolescent development and outcomes have not been extensively studied. A recent literature review found less than one percent of articles on adolescents and young adults addressed spirituality or faith-related issues (Benson, Roehlkepartain, & Rude, 2003)- The premier developmental research association for adolescents, Society for Research on Adolescence, also concluded that spirituality and religious faith (S/R) have been neglected constructs among adolescent research (King & Boyatzis, 2004). This inattention is somewhat puzzling, given that S/R has been associated with many positive outcomes in adults, including physical health (Jessor, Turbin, & Costa, 1998), pro-social attitudes (Furrow, King, & White, 2004; Hardy & Carlo, 2005), and overall life satisfaction (Zullig, Ward, & Horn, 2006). Religious beliefs in adolescents have also been linked with reduced negative outcomes, such as alcohol use (Galen & Rogers, 2004; White et al., 2006), delinquency (Walker, Ainette, Wills & Mendoza, 2007), and sexual activity (Lefkowitz, Gillen, Shearer, & Boone, 2004). Compounded with a relative lack of attention, studies of S/R have not focused on important developmental constructs among adolescents and emerging adults. Furthermore, the overall state of psychological investigation on religious, spiritual and faith issues has been hampered by a lack of clarity in conceptualization, and limitations in methodology and operational definition (Hill, 2005; HiU et al., 2000; Zinnbauer, Pargament & Scott, 1999). Developmental Constructs Development can be defined as the systematic and successive changes within human systems that occur across the lifespan (Lerner, Jacobs, & Wertlieb, 2005; p. 6). A core and enduring assumption about the developmental process is the influence of both nature and nurture on the individual (Bergen, 2007). Yet, there has been minimal discussion between the interaction of nature and nurture with respect to adolescent and emerging adult S/R development. Most studies examine the impact of nurture and the environment, for example, parents' religious involvement and subsequent influence on their adolescent children (review in Regneras, 2003), yet very few attempt to understand the possible genetic influence on S/R (Hamer, 2004). Adolescents and emerging adults are still undergoing brain maturation, with pruning of unnecessary neural connections in the frontal lobe and the increase of white matter, both of which promote more efficient abstract reasoning skills and inhibitory control (Bunge & Wright, 2007; Nagy et al. …