For Love and Money: Paying Family Caregivers

Suzanne Kunkel, Robert Applebaum, Ian Nelson

2004 · 22 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

A question of fundamental assumptions about and Families have long been the cornerstone of caregiving in the United States. For twenty-five years, we have quoted the statistic that 80 percent of the day-to-day assistance older people receive is provided by their families (U.S. General Accounting Office, 1977). The clear salience, prevalence, and centrality of family caregiving encouraged the development of a research literature about die multiple layers of this phenomenon, including motivations, meanings, and interpersonal and personal experiences of stress, burden, joy, and unfolding family dynamics. The public policy implications of a long-term-care system that is built largely on voluntary, unpaid, and mostly female participation have also received significant attention (Stone, 2000). The recent emergence of options for compensating family caregivers has raised a host of new issues. Paying family members for providing has brought to the forefront policy questions about die intrusion of public systems into family life; ethical and ideological issues about obligation and accountability; and pragmatic concerns about health, safety, and quality of services. In addition, compensating family members who provide long-term has added to the growing dialogue about economics, family values, and the nature of care work. Understanding the tensions about paying family members to provide requires an examination of some fundamental assumptions about and What is the difference between the work people do for love and the work people do for money? What does society expect and require families to do for love, without expectation of money? What are the reasonable limits to those expectations? Proponents of compensating family caregivers argue that it is a way to strengthen, expand, and sustain the natural support system. Critics of paid family worry mat compensation for some of the work will erode family obligation, create a strain on the public system, and put older people at greater risk of abuse and poor care. In this paper we discuss the dilemmas, debates, assumptions, and evidence regarding paid family caregiving. While direct payment to caregivers is die model of compensation that brings the debate into sharpest focus, it is only one of several types of compensation. Several excellent reviews of programs, policies, and models for compensation of caregivers are available (see, for example, Stone and Keigher, 1994; Polivka, 2001; Linsk et al., 1992; Simon-Rusinowitz et al., in press). In the broadest sense, financial supports for caregivers can include direct payment for services provided, tax credits, unpaid leave, and cash allowances to cover expenses related to caregiving. Here we focus only on direct payments to family members for caregiving The prevalence of this phenomenon has increased significantly over the past decade, as a direct result of the consumer-direction movement in home and community-based long-term care. In a recent inventory, Doty and Flanagan (2002) identified 139 home and community-based support programs with some consumer-directed option; half of these programs offered the option to older clients. Consumer direction is both a philosophy and a practice that emphasizes the right and ability of consumers to assess their own needs, decide how best to have those needs met, and evaluate the quality of the services provided. One of the meaningful ways that consumer direction has been put into practice is in care-provision programs in which payers (either government or private plans) allow individuals to hire and manage their own workers. A significant majority of older people who have services that they themselves direct choose to hire a family member (Doty et al., 1999; Dale et al., 2003). Consumer-directed long-term care, then, provides a focus for a review of the issues and evidence related to paying family caregivers. For purposes of discussion, we have categorized the issues as ideological, ethical, professional, and personal-interpersonal. …