Organic carbon content in soils of long-term field trial : comparison of analytical methods

Jiří Heczko, A. Gselman, Matjaž Turinek, Martina Bavec, Janja Kristl

Agricultura (Slovenia) · 2011 · 11 citations · 8 references

Concepts

Abstract

The purpose of this study was to compare two wet digestion methods, the Tyurin method and the Austrian guideline ONORM L 1081, for the determination of soil organic carbon (SOC). For this purpose the impact of conventional,� integrated,� organic� and� biodynamic� farming� systems� on� SOC� content� was� determined.� The� efༀ・ciency� of the wet oxidation methods was evaluated using the results obtained by high-temperature dry combustion. Organic carbon contents determined by the Tyurin method were higher than those from ONORM L 1081 or hightemperature combustion method. The Tyurin method overestimated the SOC content. The agreement between hightemperature dry combustion and the ONORM L 1081 results suggested that SOC in the investigated soil type and sampling horizon could be completely recovered by using wet digestion under conditions described. In the beginning period,� no� signiༀ・cant� differences� were� observed� between� the� farming� systems� under� study.� The� results� of� this� study,� however, indicate that the choice of the analytical method is important for accurate determination of SOC content.

References

8