Analysis · 2021 · 53 citations · 12 references
LawJurisprudenceEthicsMedical EthicsRisk AnalysisAbnormally Dangerous ActivitiesLiabilityMagnitude Of HarmMoral HarmsMoral RationalizationThreat Of Harm
Abstract Many activities impose risks of harm on other people. One such class of risks are those that individuals culpably impose on others, such as the risk arising from reckless driving. Do such risks in themselves constitute a harm, over and above any harm that actually eventuates? This paper considers three recent views that each answer in the affirmative. I argue that each fails to overcome what I call the ‘interference objection’. The risk of harm itself, whether taken as a subjective or an objective risk, is unable to interfere with the interests of victims in order to constitute a harm. This does not mean that a risk of harm cannot itself be wrongful, but the conclusion does weaken the moral objectionableness of impositions of risks of harm.
12
John T. Granrose · Social Theory and Practice · 1975 · 3.3K citations
Claire Finkelstein · University of Pennsylvania Law Review · 2003 · 172 citations
Harm, History, and Counterfactuals
Stephen R. Perry · Digital USD (University of San Diego) · 2003 · 94 citations · Full text
Imposing Risk: A Normative Framework
Tony Reeves · The Philosophical Quarterly · 2018 · 83 citations
Humanities, Philosophy, Ethics +8
L. E. Glynn · The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science · 2009 · 62 citations · Full text