Redescriptions Political Thought Conceptual History and Feminist Theory · 2021 · 34 citations · 3 references
HumanitiesConstitutional LawPolitical ScienceConstitutional TheoryHistoriographyPolitical HistoryGerman Social HistoryHistory Of Political TheoryPolitical IdeologyHistoriography Of Political TheoryHistory Of Political IdeasParliamentary Democracy
Scholars have portrayed Otto Kirchheimer as a precursor to contemporary Left‑Schmittianism, a view that sometimes extends to his post‑1945 relationship with Carl Schmitt. This study examines Kirchheimer’s late writings and unpublished correspondence with Schmitt to challenge the Left‑Schmittianism narrative and expose Schmitt’s attempt to use Kirchheimer for political rehabilitation in the Federal Republic via the United States. Kirchheimer vigorously opposed Schmittianism, resisted Schmitt’s instrumentalization of him, and defended modern parliamentary democracy from a left‑leaning perspective without adopting Schmittian ideas.
In the vast secondary literature on Carl Schmitt as well as on the Frankfurt School, the political and legal thinker Otto Kirchheimer is described as a forerunner of contemporary Left-Schmittianism. This view is sometimes expanded in the literature to the personal relationship between Schmitt and Kirchheimer after 1945 as well. A closer look at Kirchheimer's late work, at his unpublished correspondence with Schmitt, and at additional unpublished sources contradicts such an interpretation. In fact, Kirchheimer strongly attacked Schmittianism in German debates on constitutional theory after 1945. This article finally uncovers the extent to which Schmitt tried to instrumentalize his former doctoral student to pursue his political rehabilitation in the Federal Republic via the United States. Kirchheimer, however, took a firm stand against this attempt. In his defense of modern parliamentary democracy, Kirchheimer definitely sided with the political left of his times; but he did so without any flirtation with Schmittianism.
3
Carl Schmitt's Path to Nuremberg: A Sixty-Year Reassessment
Joseph W. Bendersky · 2007 · 28 citations